[Goanet] Cyprian Fernandes against Selma Carvalho (Response to Eddie Fernandes by Rose Fernandes)

2012-09-17 Thread Melvyn Fernandes
Dear Eddie I too echo what others have written on goanet, this matter was well and truly closed. Selma had written an article on the Goan Festival 2012 which was published in the OHeraldo in Goa, a number of readers took issue at what she had written about our community from East Africa and

Re: [Goanet] Cyprian Fernandes against Selma Carvalho (Response to Eddie Fernandes by Rose Fernandes)

2012-09-17 Thread Eddie Fernandes
Dear Rose, You are right to question the resurrection of the doddery issue even though your path is replete with thorns! I too thought that this was dead and buried until on 13th Sep I received a message from Cyprian which was also sent out to about 100 other addresses and consisted of

Re: [Goanet] Cyprian Fernandes against Selma Carvalho

2012-09-16 Thread Eva Fonseca
Hi Eddie No one disputes Selma's success nor her love for all things Goan and her tireless research on the East African Goan. Despite all her success, the point of using the word dodderer was insulting and demeaning. Point has been discussed, debated, and apology has been forthcoming. I am

Re: [Goanet] Cyprian Fernandes against Selma Carvalho

2012-09-16 Thread Mervyn Lobo
Eddie Fernandes wrote: The best testimony of the love and respect Selma has always harboured for the East African Goan community has been her work. If there is one person who has put East African Goans on the map, it is Selma Carvalho, the same person Cyprian seeks to crucify. Such are the ways

[Goanet] Cyprian Fernandes against Selma Carvalho

2012-09-15 Thread Eddie Fernandes
Folks, The woman that Cyprian Fernandes seeks to vilify has spent the last five years of her life researching East African Goans. One of the earliest columns she wrote about East African Goans on GoanVoice UK can be read here: http://www.goanvoice.org.uk/newsletter/2009/Feb/issue3/ Sitting in