My dear Jose,
** **
At the outset I appreciate the polite tone in your post. May I also state
that I do not seek your agreement to what I write nor do I lose my sleep if
you disagree. Whenever I come across wrong, incorrect or misleading
reporting /information, I try to place on record to
Permit me to interject to correct yet another misleading, false and
misinformation/ disinformation given by Santosh. The CSF is neither a
religious nor a political organisation. It is run by a layman. Further
contrary to what Santosh's 'devout' Hindu friend informed him, it is not
affiliated nor
So much for Marshall's bogus promise not to be the one to have the last word in
this thread.
He has now re-emerged to continue his crusade against people who disagree with
his religio-political agenda. This time he has decided to smear a devout Hindu
by associating him with someone called
As I had warned you earlier, Marshall will now continue to abuse and slander me
till the cows come home. The reason should be clear to everybody by now. But
that aside, in the interest of a productive discussion about secularism and
religious propaganda organizations I would like to express the
I am highly amused reading the below tripe and juvenile post. This
pontificating by a person who in an earlier debate justified / defended the
rapes, killings and destruction of property of Christians in
Kandhamalterming itas action-reaction, a la Narendra Modi. And
Santosh Helekar
claims to be a
I am sorry that Marshall has decided not to continue this discussion till the
cows come home, and prove further that I am also like Hitler and the defenders
of the holocaust. But I have to concede that he has won this argument by at
least passing his religious judgment that I am not only like
[A] First, a joke (or evidence of rank stupidity) from Marshall Mendonza :
As a sangh parivar (hindutva) apologist/sympathiser, Santosh's response
was on expected lines.
jc: Paranoia was not known to be Prevalent in Poona ... when I lived there.
[B] Marlon Menezes wrote: I would agree with
Jose Colaco wrote:
The key players in this prevalent hate are the politicians and their
lackeys. They will say anything, write anything and do anything, . to
have their 'corrupt' or 'communally corrupt' political friends in power.
You guys see any other purpose for this on-going deviousness,
As I had mentioned earlier, Marshall will now continue to abuse and slander me
till the cows come home. The reason should be clear to everybody by now. Those
of you who find this behavior of Marshall to be distressing, or who are
embarrassed for him, I apologize on his behalf. I wish I could
Those who are puzzled as to why Marshall is now abusing me and bearing false
witness against me, let me assure you that it is because he has realized that
he cannot refute the evidence that I have provided for the fact that the
Catholic-Christian Secular Forum is not a secular forum at all, but
I am surprised that Marshall did not accuse me of being a hinduvta apologist -
after all, my opinions were in line with those of Santosh's. I think we can all
agree that the CSF is a communal organization that seeks to promote what it
sees as a christian point of view by projecting its views as
From: Marshall Mendonza mmendonz...@gmail.com
2. I went through the article in question. Nowhere does it point out
any flaw in the Hindu religion. I quote from the article-
A devadasis who discovers a relationship with Christ becomes a
powerful witness in her community, according to one
I understand the position of Marshall Mendonza. Marshall is not a devout Hindu.
He is a devout Christian propagandist. Therefore, he is not expected to
understand what a devout Hindu apologist like Sandesh Anvekar would perceive as
offensive or hateful to his own religion. Marlon has nicely
As a sangh parivar (hindutva) apologist/sympathiser, Santosh's
response was on expected lines. One can let one's imagination run riot
and come to as many conclusions as one desires.Helping women in
distress come out of prostitution can in no way be said to constitute
anti-hindu sentiments as
Santosh Helekar:
Despite its name, the CSF is not a secular forum. It is a Catholic
propaganda outfit as much as the Hindu Janajagruti Samiti is a Hindu
propaganda outfit. So it is understandable that it would want to point
out the flaws in the Hindu religion, and offer the Christian gospel as
15 matches
Mail list logo
