[Goanet] Turf Wars and Goa Inquisition

2009-11-13 Thread Gilbert Lawrence
Hi Selma, Apologies are accepted. What ever happened to plain and simple: Saiba bogos. Chuk zallem? Your response shows a great finesse in getting the foot out of your mouth.:=))  Regards, GL -- Carvalho wrote: Gilbert has admitted that Goa was colonised. Gilbert my profound

Re: [Goanet] Turf Wars and Goa Inquisition

2009-11-11 Thread Carvalho
--- On Tue, 11/10/09, Santosh Helekar chimbel...@yahoo.com wrote: That is progress in my opinion. Cheers, Santosh - Santosh if you say this is progress, I take your word for it. Gilbert has admitted that Goa was colonised. Gilbert my profound apologies. :-))

Re: [Goanet] Turf Wars and Goa Inquisition

2009-11-11 Thread Frederick Noronha
I think there are other relevant issues here -- which have been discussed in detail, from many perspectives. While we may not agree with one another, ridicule of someone's perspective does not amount to a good argument. FN 2009/11/11 Carvalho elisabeth_...@yahoo.com: --- On Tue, 11/10/09,

[Goanet] Turf Wars and Goa Inquisition

2009-11-11 Thread Gilbert Lawrence
Hi Selma, Thank you for reading my post and an additional thanks for responding to it.  From your response, it appears that you did not read Teo's article and had a passing glance at my post.  Or else, we could have a more expanded dialog, to build on the issues being  reviewed. If you read

Re: [Goanet] Turf Wars and Goa Inquisition

2009-11-10 Thread Carvalho
--- On Mon, 11/9/09, Gilbert Lawrence gilbert2...@yahoo.com wrote:   Teo's article in the Herald reinforces what is apparent to anyone who looks at the Goa Inquisition and analyzes its dynamics. RESPONSE: Dear Gilbert, you seem to have a problem with anyone writing about Goa from a

Re: [Goanet] Turf Wars and Goa Inquisition

2009-11-10 Thread Santosh Helekar
Hi Selma, I do not know what it is that irked you in Gilbert's missive, other than the excessive use of misplaced scare quotes, which by the way is his trade mark. I found it surprisingly sober. No Goan historian was gratuitously trashed in it, nor was any customary attempt made at revisionism

[Goanet] Turf Wars and Goa Inquisition

2009-11-09 Thread Gilbert Lawrence
Turf Wars and the Goa Inquisition Who ever thought of such an association? (written with tongue-in-cheek)   Teo's article in the Herald reinforces what is apparent to anyone who looks at the Goa Inquisition and analyzes its dynamics. It would appear that Fr. Constantino was a young 28-yr old