Re: Extend AsyncCallback or ServiceInterfaceProxyGenerator

2011-01-15 Thread Jeff Schwartz
Done! Just a side note and slightly off topic and I hope you forgive me but every time I have to do one of these large, multi file code changes in a Web application I break into a sweat. I can't even begin to count the number of times I thought I had captured all the places in my html, javascript

Re: Extend AsyncCallback or ServiceInterfaceProxyGenerator

2011-01-14 Thread David Chandler
Hi Jeff, You must have a LOT of AsyncCallbacks in order to make it worth the pain of modifying generator code :-) Extending AsyncCallback is the technique most people use and makes sense as it's clearly application code. Perhaps one of the Eclipse refactoring tools can ease the pain? /dmc On

Re: Extend AsyncCallback or ServiceInterfaceProxyGenerator

2011-01-14 Thread Jeff Schwartz
Hi David, So far I have 146 and I am no where even nearly having a fully implemented application. Eclipse's refactoring definitely would ease the pain if I go with extending AsyncCallback :) Regarding extending ServiceInterfaceProxyGenerator, I've looked at the code and it doesn't appear to be

Re: Extend AsyncCallback or ServiceInterfaceProxyGenerator

2011-01-14 Thread Ben Imp
I'd recommend simply extending the AsyncCallback. Its undoubtedly more work up front, but its also not a hack, which is a Good Thing. Its easy to understand, and future maintainers of the program will thank you for that. Also, karma will likely stab you in the eye if you don't. -Ben On Jan 14,

Re: Extend AsyncCallback or ServiceInterfaceProxyGenerator

2011-01-14 Thread Jeff Schwartz
I made up my mind and did that hurt lol :). Even though extending ServiceInterfaceProxyGenerator is rather trivial it might be overkill for my initial needs which extending AsyncCallback can easily provide and I can alway extend ServiceInterfaceProxyGenerator at some later point anyway. So my

Re: Extend AsyncCallback or ServiceInterfaceProxyGenerator

2011-01-14 Thread Jeff Schwartz
You must have been reading my mind because your reply arrived as soon as I posted my decision. I am a devout believer in Karma and as we know it is nothing to sneeze at; my luck, I'd get hit in the head by a 600 page hard covered book dedicated to DotNot web development falling from an elevated