Re: [gpfsug-discuss] dependent versus independent filesets

2020-07-07 Thread leslie elliott
as long as your currently do not need more than 1000 on a filesystem On Wed, 8 Jul 2020 at 04:20, Daniel Kidger wrote: > It is worth noting that Independent Filesets are a relatively recent > addition to Spectrum Scale, compared to Dependant Filesets. They havesolved > some of the limitations

Re: [gpfsug-discuss] dependent versus independent filesets

2020-07-07 Thread Daniel Kidger
It is worth noting that Independent Filesets are a relatively recent addition to Spectrum Scale, compared to Dependant Filesets. They havesolved some of the limitations of the former.     My view would be to always use Independent FIlesets unless there is a particular reason to use Dependant ones.

Re: [gpfsug-discuss] dependent versus independent filesets

2020-07-07 Thread Frederick Stock
One comment about inode preallocation.  There was a time when inode creation was performance challenged but in my opinion that is no longer the case, unless you have need for file creates to complete at extreme speed.  In my experience it is the rare customer that requires extremely fast file

Re: [gpfsug-discuss] dependent versus independent filesets

2020-07-07 Thread Skylar Thompson
Ah, yes, I forgot about the quota rationale; we use independent filesets for that as well. We have run into confusion with inodes as one has to be careful to allocate inodes /and/ adjust a quota to expand a fileset. IIRC GPFS generates ENOSPC if it actually runs out of inodes, and EDQUOT if it

Re: [gpfsug-discuss] dependent versus independent filesets

2020-07-07 Thread Wahl, Edward
We also went with independent filesets for both backup (and quota) reasons for several years now, and have stuck with this across to 5.x. However we still maintain a minor number of dependent filesets for administrative use. Being able to mmbackup on many filesets at once can increase your

[gpfsug-discuss] SSUG::Digital Talk 2

2020-07-07 Thread Simon Thompson (Spectrum Scale User Group Chair)
Hi All, The next talk in the SSUG:: Digital series is taking place on Monday 13th July at 4pm BST. (Other time-zones are listed on the website!) Speaker: Lindsay Todd Topic: Best Practices for building a stretched cluster More details at:

Re: [gpfsug-discuss] dependent versus independent filesets

2020-07-07 Thread Skylar Thompson
We wanted to be able to snapshot and backup filesets separately with mmbackup, so went with independent filesets. On Tue, Jul 07, 2020 at 08:37:46AM -0500, Damir Krstic wrote: > We are deploying our new ESS and are considering moving to independent > filesets. The snapshot per fileset feature

[gpfsug-discuss] dependent versus independent filesets

2020-07-07 Thread Damir Krstic
We are deploying our new ESS and are considering moving to independent filesets. The snapshot per fileset feature appeals to us. Has anyone considered independent vs. dependent filesets and what was your reasoning to go with one as opposed to the other? Or perhaps you opted to have both on your