Re: [GRASS-user] Watershed delineation result problem

2020-10-08 Thread Massimiliano Alvioli
Hi all, I would like to briefly weigh in in this discussion, especially about the following: > 2) Of greater importance is that you can pick either one; it doesn't matter > in the real world. In 1994 I was the first environmental consultant > authorized by Oregon's Department of State Lands to

Re: [GRASS-user] Watershed delineation result problem

2020-10-07 Thread Rich Shepard
On Wed, 7 Oct 2020, ming han wrote: Thanks for sharing, I see, I will continue with GRASS version I guess. Ming, While I mis-read your 'watershed' as 'wetlands' the same argument holds true. I don't know the size of each cell in your DEM raster or whether arcGIS uses the cell center or a

Re: [GRASS-user] Watershed delineation result problem

2020-10-07 Thread ming han
Hi Rich Thanks for sharing, I see, I will continue with GRASS version I guess. Cheers Ming Rich Shepard 于2020年10月7日周三 下午1:42写道: > On Wed, 7 Oct 2020, ming han wrote: > > > Hope this email find you safe and healthy > > > > I tried watershed delineation with both ArcGIS and GRASS. but I

Re: [GRASS-user] Watershed delineation result problem

2020-10-07 Thread Rich Shepard
On Wed, 7 Oct 2020, ming han wrote: Hope this email find you safe and healthy I tried watershed delineation with both ArcGIS and GRASS. but I got different results. I was using D8 flow direction method in both ArcGIS and GRASS. My study area is very flat. Is there any tool in GRASS will

[GRASS-user] Watershed delineation result problem

2020-10-07 Thread ming han
Hi Everyone Hope this email find you safe and healthy I tried watershed delineation with both ArcGIS and GRASS. but I got different results. I was using D8 flow direction method in both ArcGIS and GRASS. My study area is very flat. Is there any tool in GRASS will generate the same

Re: [GRASS-user] Watershed delineation

2007-12-29 Thread Daniel Victoria
Hamish, Thanks for all the references! Great reading I now finally understood that r.terraflow is NOT a substitute for r.watershed when it comes to delineate basins. On Dec 28, 2007 8:50 PM, Hamish [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: ps- I think it would be nice to write a r.catchment script from

Re: [GRASS-user] Watershed delineation

2007-12-28 Thread Daniel Victoria
I tried searching through the mailing list for something about r.terraflow and the logic in the numbering scheme but could not find anything. Could some kind soul brieflly explain the logic behind it? I did find a message between Dylan and Hamish last year about joining the basins output from

Re: [GRASS-user] Watershed delineation

2007-12-28 Thread Hamish
Laura (author of r.terraflow) wrote: http://article.gmane.org/gmane.comp.gis.grass.devel/1442 Aleksey Naumov wrote: (b) BTW, what controls the size of those subwatersheds saved in the swatershed map? (Something similat to threshold in r.watershed may be nice...) Laura: In Terraflow the