[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-25 Thread ranju radha
when i wrote non-essential, i was not particularly addressng you there are poeple (scholars and scholars in the making) who innocently believe that only Dalits who assert are "essentialising" and not the "secular" selves. i dont know whther u think like that or not as far as i know, u have shown th

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-25 Thread venukm
Ranjith, I feel tempted to respond ,but first decided not to do so before being able to decipher what you had meant by "non-essentialist"! Could you help me? Anyway, this is my response according to my understanding of the term. I find lots of people here and I certainly do represent that secti

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-25 Thread C.K. Vishwanath
and other vested interests had proved dwey's famous statement -politics is the shadow of big business. --- On Wed, 25/3/09, Afthab Ellath wrote: > From: Afthab Ellath > Subject: [GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM > candidate-Kancha Illaiah > To: green

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-24 Thread Afthab Ellath
ticular > character of indian society. > This is just a concern of any humman being who believes in social > justice,democracy,freedom etc. > > --- On Tue, 24/3/09, ranju radha wrote: > > > From: ranju radha > > Subject: [GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati a

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-24 Thread C.K. Vishwanath
alit assertion.this is the particular character of indian society. This is just a concern of any humman being who believes in social justice,democracy,freedom etc. --- On Tue, 24/3/09, ranju radha wrote: > From: ranju radha > Subject: [GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM >

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-24 Thread ranju radha
exactly i wont allow any one to steal that moment from me and unlike many politically correct secular/marxist/feminist/non-essentialist friends, i am a kind of person who believ in blasphemy so i need not face any secular dilemma this is the time to be confident and say to oneself YES WE CAN an

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-24 Thread damodar prasad
I would like to quote here Naomi Klien from an interview she gave after Obama came to power. this is it: http://www.progressive.org/mag/intv0209.html What was your first reaction to Obama’s victory? Naomi Klein: Well, I made a really conscious choice that I was going to enjoy the night. Obviously,

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-24 Thread ranju radha
for me, i really feel proud and honored to be alive to see Mayavati and Obama i love the moment On Tue, Mar 24, 2009 at 6:40 PM, salimtk wrote: > and that secular dilemma is historically embedded with criticism and > compromise to various parties intellectually and maintained the emotional >

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-24 Thread salimtk
and that secular dilemma is historically embedded with criticism and compromise to various parties intellectually and maintained the emotional detatchment. that's why no feeling of happiness when seeing maya on stage. how can one intellectually be happy :) On Tue, Mar 24, 2009 at 1:02 PM, ranju

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-24 Thread ranju radha
>>>Or, can Maya appoint millions of Dalits in Government jobs when vacancies don't exist? maya is yet to become the "national" maya else she should have been in a position to create "vacancies" out of nothing which her sacred thread bearing politicians/academics/bureacrts etc etc have been doing

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-24 Thread damodar prasad
is > essential.Here,The over all dominance of the brahmanic social order Play > their dirty games. > > --- On Sun, 22/3/09, Afthab Ellath wrote: > > > From: Afthab Ellath > > Subject: [GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM > candidate-Kancha Illaiah >

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-22 Thread C.K. Vishwanath
gt; From: Afthab Ellath > Subject: [GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM > candidate-Kancha Illaiah > To: greenyouth@googlegroups.com > Date: Sunday, 22 March, 2009, 4:44 PM > I found the points > raised by Salim in his first post, comparing the upper > caste/co

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-22 Thread venukm
> > > which > > > > > will decide the future  political equations > > > > > just some preliminary observations.. > > > > > >   On Sat, Mar 21, 2009 at 7:20 PM, C.K. Vishwanath < > > > > > ck_vishwanath2...@yahoo.com> wrote: >

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-22 Thread venukm
; > >> ideological purity at all. > > > >> mayavati is also a victim of this > > > >> system.we have to remember the dalit criticsm of left is that > > socialist > > > >> brahmins are more dangeorous...and we can remember k.illaiah's

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-22 Thread venukm
ch fronts,having no > > > >> ideological purity at all. > > > >> mayavati is also a victim of this > > > >> system.we have to remember the dalit criticsm of left is that > > socialist > > > >> brahmins are more dangeorous...and we can remember k.il

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-22 Thread venukm
ch fronts,having no > > > >> ideological purity at all. > > > >> mayavati is also a victim of this > > > >> system.we have to remember the dalit criticsm of left is that > > socialist > > > >> brahmins are more dangeorous...and we can remember k.il

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-22 Thread venukm
ch fronts,having no > > > >> ideological purity at all. > > > >> mayavati is also a victim of this > > > >> system.we have to remember the dalit criticsm of left is that > > socialist > > > >> brahmins are more dangeorous...and we can remember k.il

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-22 Thread venukm
ch fronts,having no > > > >> ideological purity at all. > > > >> mayavati is also a victim of this > > > >> system.we have to remember the dalit criticsm of left is that > > socialist > > > >> brahmins are more dangeorous...and we can remember k.il

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-22 Thread venukm
ch fronts,having no > > > >> ideological purity at all. > > > >> mayavati is also a victim of this > > > >> system.we have to remember the dalit criticsm of left is that > > socialist > > > >> brahmins are more dangeorous...and we can remember k.il

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-22 Thread venukm
ch fronts,having no > > > >> ideological purity at all. > > > >> mayavati is also a victim of this > > > >> system.we have to remember the dalit criticsm of left is that > > socialist > > > >> brahmins are more dangeorous...and we can remember k.il

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-22 Thread venukm
ch fronts,having no > > > >> ideological purity at all. > > > >> mayavati is also a victim of this > > > >> system.we have to remember the dalit criticsm of left is that > > socialist > > > >> brahmins are more dangeorous...and we can remember k.il

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-22 Thread Afthab Ellath
parties were so dominant and they can > > >> > manipulate republican party very easily. > > >> > > Up is in deep debt.and she has to attract capital for > > >> > development.and mayavait has to bring more political > > >> > constituencies int

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-21 Thread venukm
-option of dalits in hindutva > >> fold very fastly.the neo-hindutva identity of these dalits can be the best > >> resources for hinduva empire bulding ala modi model in gujarath. > >> Another trap of golobalisation period is the concentration of power in > >>

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-21 Thread salimtk
fold very fastly.the neo-hindutva identity of these dalits can be the best >> resources for hinduva empire bulding ala modi model in gujarath. >> Another trap of golobalisation period is the concentration of power in >> judiciary rather than in legislature affects the rea

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-21 Thread ranju radha
r in > judiciary rather than in legislature affects the real politicisation process > as well. > How is to address these issues ?this is a survival question of mayavati > politics in india. > > > > > > --- On Sat, 21/3/09, venukm wrote: > > > From: venukm > > Sub

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-21 Thread C.K. Vishwanath
#x27;s idea of social consciosness > is far off from up context. > > > > What ever may be the limitations,she can  give a > confidence.I thik that this confidence is the most > important. > > --- On Sat, 21/3/09, venukm > wrote: > > > > > > > >

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-21 Thread venukm
dkar's idea of social consciosness is far off from up context. > > What ever may be the limitations,she can  give a confidence.I thik that this > confidence is the most important. > --- On Sat, 21/3/09, venukm wrote: > > > > > > > From: venukm > > Subj

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-21 Thread C.K. Vishwanath
il society india.Ambedkar's idea of social consciosness is far off from up context. What ever may be the limitations,she can give a confidence.I thik that this confidence is the most important. --- On Sat, 21/3/09, venukm wrote: > From: venukm > Subject: [GreenYouth] Re: Left's m

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-21 Thread sreenivas v.p
: From: venukm Subject: [GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah To: "Green Youth Movement" Date: Saturday, 21 March, 2009, 1:50 PM While Illaiah is obviously complaining about left's moralism, isn't he himself forging ahead wit

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-21 Thread salimtk
though i don't have any intention to formulate political stand based on the comments from the so called 'neutral' spectators of TV news, i feel happy hearing them saying when they see mayavati on news as future PM. some comments: "see where india is heading to" "see an illeterate gonna be indian pm

[GreenYouth] Re: Left's moralism and Mayawati as PM candidate-Kancha Illaiah

2009-03-21 Thread venukm
While Illaiah is obviously complaining about left's moralism, isn't he himself forging ahead with moralistic arguments in favour of Mayavati? What if Mayavati happens to be just another woman, (like Indira Gandhi or Sushma Swaraj, who would compromise with the brutal ( patriarchal , brahmanica