Re: [gmx-users] Binding energy of membrane protein to the membrane lipids

2014-05-08 Thread Victor Sojo
Dear all, I'm trying to determine the binding energy of a membrane protein to the membrane. Ultimately I need to compare the binding energy of the same protein to two similar types of lipid, the hypothesis being that there should be a slight difference. I considered two options: alchemical

Re: [gmx-users] Binding energy of membrane protein to the membrane lipids

2014-05-08 Thread Justin Lemkul
On 5/8/14, 3:38 PM, Victor Sojo wrote: Dear all, I'm trying to determine the binding energy of a membrane protein to the membrane. Ultimately I need to compare the binding energy of the same protein to two similar types of lipid, the hypothesis being that there should be a slight difference.

Re: [gmx-users] Binding energy of membrane protein to the membrane lipids

2014-02-24 Thread sojovictor
Thanks so much, Justin! Your comments and paper are very helpful indeed. With by eye I meant I just need to know whether one is bigger than the other, but you're complete right: no need to speak in qualitative terms when I can quantitatively determine DeltaDeltaG. Thanks again! Victor Sojo

Re: [gmx-users] Binding energy of membrane protein to the membrane lipids

2014-02-23 Thread Justin Lemkul
On 2/23/14, 10:36 AM, sojovictor wrote: Dear all, I would like to find the difference in the energy of binding or insertion of a protein into two different types of phospholipid membranes (plus water and ions). i.e., my hypothesis is that the energy should be lower with one type of membrane

Re: [gmx-users] Binding energy of membrane protein to the membrane lipids

2014-02-23 Thread sojovictor
Thanks, Justin! That's really helpful indeed. You are correct, I want to know what's the energy change in replacing one lipid with the other, hypothesising that going to the wrong lipid will imply an energetic cost. Via umbrella sampling, I would thus: 1) Set up a full system with protein,

Re: [gmx-users] Binding energy of membrane protein to the membrane lipids

2014-02-23 Thread Justin Lemkul
On 2/23/14, 11:54 AM, sojovictor wrote: Thanks, Justin! That's really helpful indeed. You are correct, I want to know what's the energy change in replacing one lipid with the other, hypothesising that going to the wrong lipid will imply an energetic cost. Via umbrella sampling, I would thus: