Re: [h-cost] Experimental Archaeology (was 1968 SCA views of medieval clothing)

2005-09-06 Thread Lavolta Press
I don't think that how you feel about a task in the here and now, is any guarantee of how someone else in another era felt about it. Living without flush toilets is a different experience when you know in the back of your mind that you can return to modern conveniences any time you want.

Re: [h-cost] Experimental Archaeology (was 1968 SCA views of medieval clothing)

2005-09-05 Thread Lavolta Press
Furthermore, I would think you'd have to be discovering something new (to modern eyes). For example, when the 20th person makes an 1850 chemise using original instructions and methods, and it's pretty much the same process for them as for the first 19 people, is it really experimental any

Re: [h-cost] Experimental Archaeology (was 1968 SCA views of medieval clothing)

2005-09-05 Thread Lavolta Press
What makes it archaeology, as opposed to just learning a task or craft, even if one of the past? Fran [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: To clarify, I refered to experiential archaeology - that is learning things about the past by doing them. Experimental archeology is, as you say, something somewhat