Re: Do functions exist?

1993-11-22 Thread Jeff Dalton
All (all?) I'm proposing is to print them out. Yes we do, and it's fine for the *implementation* to print such things out. But it is NOT fine to cross the dividing line of (1) the implementation, and (2) the language it implements. As I believe I have made abundantly clear a showFun

Do functions exist?

1993-11-19 Thread David Barton
Greg Michaelson writes: Incidentally, my point about not bothering to evaluate functional programs whose final values are functions was serious. Presumably, people don't generally write programs that return functions as final values? I suppose it depends on what you call a

Re: Do functions exist?

1993-11-19 Thread John Launchbury
John says we can't go from a function to its concrete representation ie E - [E] - OK. He hints that implementations are from concrete representations to real functions ie [E] - E. I disagree profoundly. I'm not surprised you disagree. I hinted no such thing. Implementations manipulate

Do functions exist?

1993-11-19 Thread Greg Michaelson
John says we can't go from a function to its concrete representation ie E - [E] - OK. He hints that implementations are from concrete representations to real functions ie [E] - E. I disagree profoundly. Implementations are from concrete representations to concrete representations. Suppose E1 is