Re: [hibernate-dev] trunk project layout

2009-09-11 Thread Steve Ebersole
Its not the release per-se alone. These are not all directly related so its hard to explain... I outlined in the other email to max about checking out and needing to immediately install everything. Granted, it depends on exactly what you want to do, but that's the basic requirement; for example,

Re: [hibernate-dev] trunk project layout

2009-09-11 Thread Max Rydahl Andersen
>> 1 project with submodules, all have the same version thus the parent is >> the reactor ? >> >> btw. I remember we initially did this parent were put in a dir on its >> own to make eclipse >> happy - that is not really a concern anymore since later eclipse >> versions can handle >> having a root

Re: [hibernate-dev] trunk project layout

2009-09-11 Thread Max Rydahl Andersen
In the words of Arnaud (commenter on the blog), isn't the GateIn approach what you want ? 1 project with submodules, all have the same version thus the parent is the reactor ? Different discussions. The "GateIn approach" is *functionally* no different than what we have today Max. The o

Re: [hibernate-dev] trunk project layout

2009-09-11 Thread Steve Ebersole
On Fri, 2009-09-11 at 14:07 +0200, Max Rydahl Andersen wrote: > In the words of Arnaud (commenter on the blog), isn't the GateIn > approach what you want ? > > 1 project with submodules, all have the same version thus the parent is > the reactor ? Different discussions. The "GateIn approach" is

Re: [hibernate-dev] trunk project layout

2009-09-11 Thread Hardy Ferentschik
Hi, I am just wondering if you could elaborate what exactly the problem with the release. I think so far you are the only one who actually did a release for Core using the current setup. Hibernate Search and Validator also use the maven release plugin and there is works just fine. Admittedl

Re: [hibernate-dev] trunk project layout

2009-09-11 Thread Galder Zamarreno
On 09/11/2009 02:07 PM, Max Rydahl Andersen wrote: > In the words of Arnaud (commenter on the blog), isn't the GateIn > approach what you want ? > > 1 project with submodules, all have the same version thus the parent is > the reactor ? > > btw. I remember we initially did this parent were put in

Re: [hibernate-dev] trunk project layout

2009-09-11 Thread Max Rydahl Andersen
In the words of Arnaud (commenter on the blog), isn't the GateIn approach what you want ? 1 project with submodules, all have the same version thus the parent is the reactor ? btw. I remember we initially did this parent were put in a dir on its own to make eclipse happy - that is not really a

[hibernate-dev] trunk project layout

2009-09-10 Thread Steve Ebersole
I am not happy with the way hibernate is built currently (see http://in.relation.to/12116.lace for part of the details). One thing I do not like currently is the way "release related" stuff and "code" are mixed. To me, I'd really prefer that "release" be something that was a separate "lifecycle"