Re: Re[2]: [Hibernate] Check named queries

2004-07-01 Thread Oleg Proudnikov
Hi, Aaron wrote: [snip] Those cases where Hibernate generates SQL that is not compatible with a specific database should be treated as bugs in Hibernate. (i.e. The Dialect implementation is incorrect.) What I would like to see is one of two types of exception thrown during HQL compilation: 1)

RE: Re[2]: [Hibernate] Check named queries

2004-06-30 Thread Aaron Knauf
> > I suggest that named query validation be done by the > > Dialect implementation, rather than by checking against a live DB. > > Why the dialect? It doesn't know about the schema, does it? Ok, I guess I wasn't being particularly precise when I suggested the Dialect. The complete validat

RE: Re[2]: [Hibernate] Check named queries

2004-06-30 Thread Joshua Davis
See my comments below. (Please remember that I'm the FNG around here so my comments might be dumb ;->). > -Original Message- > From: [EMAIL PROTECTED] > [mailto:[EMAIL PROTECTED] On > Behalf Of Aaron Knauf > Sent: Tuesday, June 29, 2004 6:24 PM > Subject: RE

RE: Re[2]: [Hibernate] Check named queries

2004-06-29 Thread Aaron Knauf
I agree with Max. Sorry for the long email, but I wanted to express a particular way of looking at this problem, as much as an opinion on how best to solve it. To summarize for those not interested in the long-winded version, I suggest that named query validation be done by the Dialect implemen