Re: [HOT] Waterway Tags

2015-01-22 Thread Eric Sibert
I think we should follow the example of the "abandoned:" namespace, as in http://wiki.osm.org/wiki/Key:abandoned , and use something like: I would suggest to discuss this first on tagging list, especially now that they are already discussing intermittent waterway. Eric

Re: [HOT] Waterway Tags

2015-01-22 Thread Iván Sánchez Ortega
El Jueves 22. enero 2015 01.18.52 Blake Girardot escribió: > As to the tagging suggestion, Ralph, I _think_ the current best practice > is to tag an intermittent stream or river like this: > > waterway=river (or stream) > intermittent=yes > or > seasonal=yes I think we should follow the example o

Re: [HOT] Waterway Tags

2015-01-22 Thread AYTOUN RALPH
Hi Blake and Russell, thanks...you have pointed me to the lists I need to approach regarding this. Great help and saved me a lot of nosing around. I understand some of the problems of waterways. As Senior Cartographer for Philip's World Reference Atlases I had to find a happy medium trying to make

Re: [HOT] Waterway Tags

2015-01-21 Thread Russell Deffner
I probably should have specified the thread is titled "waterway=wadi problem" and this link is to the first (I think) message in the thread: https://lists.openstreetmap.org/pipermail/tagging/2015-January/020946.html =Russ ___ HOT mailing list HOT@openstre

Re: [HOT] Waterway Tags

2015-01-21 Thread Blake Girardot
I think water and waterways are some of the most difficult to map and tag features there are, even when things are simple and clear in imagery. To Ralph's points: As to the tagging suggestion, Ralph, I _think_ the current best practice is to tag an intermittent stream or river like this: wat

Re: [HOT] Waterway Tags

2015-01-21 Thread Russell Deffner
Hi, I'm no expert in the waterway arena, however I wanted to point out that there is currently a pretty in-depth discussion of waterway tagging (including some suggestions to discontinue using waterway=wadi) on the Tagging mailing list, you can find the thread archive here: https://lists.openstree

Re: [HOT] Waterway Tags

2015-01-21 Thread john whelan
I have difficulties with water I must confess. I'm mapping from a satellite image taken an a particular day. All I see is water, not wadi etc. If its a River I'm supposed to note which direction it flows. My eyesight isn't that good. A wide river isn't a problem but when is a Stream a River or

[HOT] Waterway Tags

2015-01-21 Thread AYTOUN RALPH
I would like to raise the issue of tags for *waterway=river*, *waterway=stream* and* waterway=wadi.* The problem that exists with the existing tags is that there is no visual difference on the map for a stream (perennial) and a stream (intermittent) and the only other option is wadi which gives a b