Re: [HOT] Central African Republic import of WRI data

2013-07-02 Thread Ben Abelshausen
Hi, I'm also prepared to contribute to finish this task and improve the CAR-map. The WRI road-dataset isn't that big but it's not an easy task and still a lot of work. I'm not sure a few mappers will be enough but it would be nice to at least be able to start some work. I was just waiting on the

Re: [HOT] Central African Republic import of WRI data

2013-07-02 Thread Pierre Béland
African Republic import of WRI data Andrew, Actually I agree, but I discussed this before with some other OSM/HOT people (It's been so long I don't remember when or who) and it was said that using inaccurate data might be worse than nothing. For the CAR specifically I think using the data might

Re: [HOT] Central African Republic import of WRI data

2013-07-02 Thread Ben Abelshausen
-- From: Pierre Béland pierz...@yahoo.fr Sent: 2/07/2013 19:45 To: hot@openstreetmap.org Cc: Severin MENARD severin.men...@gmail.com; Andrew Buckandrew.r.b...@gmail.com; Ben Abelshausen ben.abelshau...@gmail.com Subject: Re: [HOT] Central African Republic import of WRI data To my point

Re: [HOT] Central African Republic import of WRI data

2013-07-02 Thread Andrew Buck
Oh, I forgot that the tasking manager was being used in this import. Since that allows us to track the progress of the import and easily keep track of what is not yet imported then I withdraw my previous objection to a partial import. My concern was mainly that we would lose some of the data

Re: [HOT] Central African Republic import of WRI data

2013-07-02 Thread Pierre Béland
hot@openstreetmap.org Cc : Severin MENARD severin.men...@gmail.com; Andrew Buck andrew.r.b...@gmail.com Envoyé le : Mardi 2 juillet 2013 15h04 Objet : RE: [HOT] Central African Republic import of WRI data Hi, Many of these things have been discussed and considered. This is why we suggested

[HOT] Central African Republic import of WRI data

2013-06-30 Thread Severin MENARD
Hi, Sorry to jump so late into this discussion. Actually I am waiting for an answer from the imports list since Mid May. I put it below. So we would like to know if in the case of using a ODbL compatible dataset as a guide for tracing over Bing Imagery (because of the lack of geometrical

Re: [HOT] Central African Republic import of WRI data

2013-06-30 Thread Andrew Buck
In answer to your question on imports, I think the general consensus is that tracing from bing and then copying attributes from this dataset would not be considered an import, it is merely a second source of data used in manual mapping. One other thing to consider is the 'utilsplugin2' which has

Re: [HOT] Central African Republic import of WRI data

2013-06-30 Thread Andrew Buck
Severin, The nodes are re-used by the 'replace geometry' tool. So what it does is when you select the two ways and run the tool it takes the old way and tries to 'move' as many of the old nodes (with their ID numbers in the DB) to the positions you chose for your new way, as well as copying over