Re: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience?

2024-03-07 Thread Dave Beagle
Here’s the problem. When you “secure” the mainframe with LESS SECURE platforms, you actually open yourself up to hacks. Splunk has been hacked quite frequently.  https://www.securityweek.com/high-severity-vulnerability-patched-in-splunk-enterprise/amp/ Sent from Yahoo Mail for iPhone On

Re: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience?

2024-03-07 Thread Charles Mills
Well sure, over-reliance on any one "solution" as a panacea is foolish. I had prospects tell me "we don't have any security issues -- we have RACF." CM On Thu, 7 Mar 2024 02:08:26 +, kekronbekron wrote: >> You are making a mistake if you discount the effectiveness of >>

Re: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience?

2024-03-07 Thread kekronbekron
Awesome, I know & do tell you directly that you're doing excellent & needed work like zOS-ifying distributed tools. On Thursday, March 7th, 2024 at 15:08, David Crayford <0595a051454b-dmarc-requ...@listserv.ua.edu> wrote: > > On 7 Mar 2024, at 10:08 am, kekronbekron > >

Re: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience?

2024-03-07 Thread David Crayford
> On 7 Mar 2024, at 10:08 am, kekronbekron > <02dee3fcae33-dmarc-requ...@listserv.ua.edu> wrote: > >> You are making a mistake if you discount the effectiveness of >> industry-standard tools in analyzing mainframe data. > > Let me clarify... I'm not saying don't use it at all. Just saying

Re: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience?

2024-03-06 Thread ITschak Mugzach
I think that SMF itself is not sufficient for security alerts. Only part of the activity is recorded and the event is not understood by the auditors. A good example is adding a dataset to APF by a sysprog. He got a call the first time, saying this is his day job, second call, but as the wolf and

Re: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience?

2024-03-06 Thread kekronbekron
> You are making a mistake if you discount the effectiveness of > industry-standard tools in analyzing mainframe data. Let me clarify... I'm not saying don't use it at all. Just saying that there seems to be a tendency to lean too heavily on it, after it has gotten its foot through the door

Re: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience?

2024-03-06 Thread Dave Beagle
Any contractor who elevates his/her security access should immediately be fired and possibly reported to authorities. Unless of course the security people at the shop were negligent in giving him the authority to elevate him/herself. The shop I was referring to in which I worked, had mainframe

Re: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience?

2024-03-06 Thread Charles Mills
I of course saw first-hand a lot of mainframe -> SIEM or Splunk integrations, and they ran the gamut. Some were as you describe; some were quite effective. The worst I saw was one company that was printing an SMF report to spool, using a mainframe product to convert the spooled report to a PDF,

Re: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience?

2024-03-06 Thread kekronbekron
Exactly. I have my reservations on whether we as mainframe folks are choosing this (log analytics products) or are defaulting to it because no one is challenging for appropriate options from the mainframe technical side. For an org, there is of course the valid point of correlation that Charles

Re: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience?

2024-03-06 Thread Dave Beagle
We used Splunk at a former employer. Well, not really used it. An auditor “suggested” we implement it to “improve” our mainframe security. The auditor knew nothing about mainframe security. Likely read about Splunk somewhere or saw a session on it at a conference. And of course the topic of

Re: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience?

2024-03-06 Thread kekronbekron
> I guess you might say that the whole point of products such as these is > converting dense "strings & numbers" into logs. I agree, except that I think the goal is not to squirrel metrics into logs, but to get metrics and/or logs (actual SYSLOG) to tooling used outside of mainframe. > no, we

Re: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience?

2024-03-06 Thread Charles Mills
I guess you might say that the whole point of products such as these is converting dense "strings & numbers" into logs. A mainframe security "event" is surely as significant to the enterprise as a Linux server security event -- it makes sense to many enterprises to get it into their enterprise

Re: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience?

2024-03-05 Thread kekronbekron
I don't understand this at all... we all know that SMF is not a log, it's a whole bunch of strings & mostly numbers... metrics. Why has it become acceptable to send metrics to a log search tool, knowing full well that these are different categories with different solutions. Splunk etc. are meant

Re: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience?

2024-03-04 Thread Timothy Sipples
Steve Estle wrote: >We are embarking on an endeavor to explore sending logics to a >tool called Sumologic(sumologic.com). For those who are unaware, >Sumologic is a competitor to Splunk and contains a very powerful real >time log parsing analytics engine which can be used to build dashboards,

Re: EXTERNAL EMAIL: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience?

2024-03-04 Thread Paul Feller
Mills Sent: Monday, March 4, 2024 7:05 PM To: IBM-MAIN@LISTSERV.UA.EDU Subject: Re: EXTERNAL EMAIL: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience? Thanks for the shout-out, Jerry! (I was the principal developer of said product.) I think BMC now calls the product AMI Defender. (I have no financial interest

Re: EXTERNAL EMAIL: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience?

2024-03-04 Thread Charles Mills
. Charles -Original Message- From: IBM Mainframe Discussion List [mailto:IBM-MAIN@LISTSERV.UA.EDU] On Behalf Of Jerry Whitteridge Sent: Monday, March 4, 2024 12:12 PM To: IBM-MAIN@LISTSERV.UA.EDU Subject: Re: EXTERNAL EMAIL: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience? We used a product

Re: EXTERNAL EMAIL: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience?

2024-03-04 Thread Jerry Whitteridge
Services jerry.whitteri...@albertsons.com 480 578 7889 -Original Message- From: IBM Mainframe Discussion List On Behalf Of Steve Estle Sent: Monday, March 4, 2024 11:43 AM To: IBM-MAIN@LISTSERV.UA.EDU Subject: EXTERNAL EMAIL: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience? All, We are embarking

Re: ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience?

2024-03-04 Thread ITschak Mugzach
Technically, it is not an issue. You can send everything using Rexx (I can supply a sample for syslog). The main issue is converting the input to a format familiar to the syslog parser. In my code I use CEF. So, what are your input sources? ITschak *| **Itschak Mugzach | Director | SecuriTeam

ZOS Sending Logs to Sumologic Experience?

2024-03-04 Thread Steve Estle
All, We are embarking on an endeavor to explore sending logics to a tool called Sumologic(sumologic.com). For those who are unaware, Sumologic is a competitor to Splunk and contains a very powerful real time log parsing analytics engine which can be used to build dashboards, alerts, and more.