Re: allowable questions (was Re www...)

2001-04-08 Thread Scott Bradner
I think we need to have a clear discussion about which kinds of NDAs are compatible with IESG duty. see RCC 2026 section 10.2 - the simple answer is "none" Scott

Re: allowable questions (was Re www...)

2001-04-08 Thread James P. Salsman
Patrik, If you or Ned are not already aware from the context of my disputed question and my previous posts, I tried private emails and phone calls, prior to my working group question, which was only a footnote to a longer list of requested solutions which still seem like entirely constructive

Re: allowable questions (was Re www...)

2001-04-08 Thread John Day
At 14:00 -0700 4/8/01, James P. Salsman wrote: Patrik, If you or Ned are not already aware from the context of my disputed question and my previous posts, I tried private emails and phone calls, prior to my working group question, which was only a footnote to a longer list of requested solutions

Re: I-D ACTION:draft-wildgrube-gnp-01.txt

2001-04-08 Thread Rahmat M. Samik-Ibrahim
Lloyd Wood wrote: That was the odd one out, but I'm getting 404 Not found for other recently-announced drafts. Perhaps uploading before announcing would be good. Simple Question: What should I do if I could not find a internet draft that was announced as an I-D action in

Re: allowable questions (was Re www...)

2001-04-08 Thread Valdis . Kletnieks
On Sun, 08 Apr 2001 22:17:02 EDT, John Day said: I do not know about other countries, but I do know that the US government has taken action against companies for announcing products and then deciding later to not offer those products. Hence, most people do not talk about possible future

Re: I-D ACTION:draft-wildgrube-gnp-01.txt

2001-04-08 Thread John C Klensin
--On Monday, April 09, 2001 10:11 AM +0700 "Rahmat M. Samik-Ibrahim" [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: That was the odd one out, but I'm getting 404 Not found for other recently-announced drafts. Perhaps uploading before announcing would be good. Simple Question: What should I do if I could

Re: allowable questions (was Re www...)

2001-04-08 Thread Dave Crocker
At 02:00 PM 4/8/2001, James P. Salsman wrote: I tried private emails and phone calls, prior to my working group question, which was only a footnote to a longer list of requested solutions which still seem like entirely constructive critisism to me. This appears to be the core of the problem.