Re: The 'failure' of SMTP RE: DNS Choices: Was: [ietf-dkim] Re: Last Call: 'DomainKeys

2006-12-03 Thread Dave Crocker
Paul Robinson wrote: This is not an economic battle. People think it is, because they see the motive behind spam as profit, and if you make spam expensive enough the battle will be won, but it will always be possible for them to make it cheap enough somehow. soapbox It's clear that profit

Re: Something better than DNS?

2006-12-03 Thread Dave Crocker
John Levine wrote: ICANN has not to date dealt very effectively with these issues, but they are real issues that will have a great effect on people who use the DNS every day, and they're not technical issues, since all of the alternatives are equally feasible technically. At its base, IDN is

Re: Something better than DNS?

2006-12-03 Thread John L
ICANN has not to date dealt very effectively with these issues, but they are real issues that will have a great effect on people who use the DNS every day, and they're not technical issues, since all of the alternatives are equally feasible technically. At its base, IDN is a technical matter.

Re: Something better than DNS?

2006-12-03 Thread Dave Crocker
-- Dave Crocker Brandenburg InternetWorking bbiw.net John L wrote: At its base, IDN is a technical matter. That is the realm of the IETF, not ICANN. ICANN can deploy and administer solutions developed in the IETF, but it cannot create them. That's not its job and it's not its

Re: Something better than DNS?

2006-12-03 Thread Frank Ellermann
John L wrote: There are both technical issues and non-technical issues. [...] BTW, I liked your travel-sitefinder statement on behalf of ALAC. Frank ___ Ietf mailing list Ietf@ietf.org https://www1.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/ietf