Re: Last Call: draft-housley-rfc2050bis-01.txt (The Internet Numbers Registry System) to Informational RFC

2013-05-11 Thread Eliot Lear
Dave, Just on this point: On 5/11/13 2:36 AM, David Conrad wrote: There isn't any mention of privacy [2] considerations in the draft. True. The document is documenting current practices and policies. At this point in time, I'm unaware of a global privacy practice or policy that is

Re: Last Call: draft-housley-rfc2050bis-01.txt (The Internet Numbers Registry System) to Informational RFC

2013-05-11 Thread Eliot Lear
Uch... you can see where my head is: On 5/11/13 2:14 PM, Eliot Lear wrote: It's probably worth saying that the various PDPs SHOULD address policy considerations. How they address them is a matter for them, individually. s/policy considerations/privacy considerations/ Grr... Eliot

Re: Last Call: draft-housley-rfc2050bis-01.txt (The Internet Numbers Registry System) to Informational RFC

2013-05-11 Thread SM
Hi David, At 18:36 10-05-2013, David Conrad wrote: Sure, but it is also looking towards the remaining few IPv4 allocations that will be made over the next few years. I am looking at the draft from an IETF perspective. There is IPv4 address space for protocol assignments. It could be said

Re: Last Call: draft-housley-rfc2050bis-01.txt (The Internet Numbers Registry System) to Informational RFC

2013-05-11 Thread Brian E Carpenter
On 12/05/2013 03:17, SM wrote: ... The fact that the IPv6 address pool is very large does not remove the fact that it is a not an infinite resource and thus, constraints must be applied to allocation policy. The constraints are not set by the IETF. It's up to other communities to see what

Re: Last Call: draft-housley-rfc2050bis-01.txt (The Internet Numbers Registry System) to Informational RFC

2013-05-11 Thread SM
At 13:08 11-05-2013, Tom Vest wrote: Sorry, but unless you can point to some relevant real-world examples of self-executing, self-sustaining principles, or you're a nihilist and don't really believe that such things as principles exist at all, this is a patently false, bordering on nonsense