Re: 1918bis

2005-02-05 Thread Brian Haberman
My understanding is that the IESG (or some part of it) is having the DNS text looked at by the DNS directorate. Regards, Brian On Feb 4, 2005, at 15:29, Sam Hartman wrote: Tony == Tony Hain [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Tony and now the replacement ULA space is unable to be published Tony as

Re: 1918bis

2005-02-04 Thread Sam Hartman
Tony == Tony Hain [EMAIL PROTECTED] writes: Tony and now the replacement ULA space is unable to be published Tony as it is dragging out in an interminable discuss state. I see no discusses on draft-ietf-ipv6-unique-local-addr. I have not been following the document though since I

Re: 1918bis

2005-02-03 Thread Spencer Dawkins
Hi, Tony, It is long past time to get over any thoughts about reclaiming IPv4 space. It will never happen. No organization is going to give up any they have until we are well past the point where anyone cares about getting more. IPv4 has reached the point of success/failure and is a dead end

1918bis

2005-02-02 Thread John Kristoff
Tony, [ Posting this to the main ietf list as well as to you directly in case you don't see it there. I realize this may be a controversial topic that results in an endless thread of heated arguments, but I'll take my chances since I'm curious to hear reasons for or against the draft. ]

RE: 1918bis

2005-02-02 Thread Tony Hain
in the long run because IPv4 is effectively finished. It is inadequate for serious large scale deployments even now, and as the number of network attached appliances continues to drive up the number of addresses in use per person the problem only becomes more acute. The only reason to bother with a 1918bis

Re: [Ietf] RE: I-D ACTION:draft-hain-1918bis-00.txt

2004-04-23 Thread Iljitsch van Beijnum
On 23-apr-04, at 3:40, Michel Py wrote: draft-hain-1918bis-00.txt Although I don't think it belongs in the draft, could you post some real examples of addressing plans that would use that much private space Yes, the draft is a little light on justification

[Ietf] RE: I-D ACTION:draft-hain-1918bis-00.txt

2004-04-22 Thread Michel Py
Tony, draft-hain-1918bis-00.txt Although I don't think it belongs in the draft, could you post some real examples of addressing plans that would use that much private space (we are talking about 10/8 plus four other class A). I was wondering if it would not be easier to make a case requesting