Re: IASA BCP Conflict of Interest Clause?

2004-12-23 Thread Brian E Carpenter
[EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: I think this is sufficient as well. a. On 22 dec 2004, at 15.22, Harald Tveit Alvestrand wrote: The IAOC will establish and publish rules to handle conflict of interest situations. Yes, I think so. Profiting from a conflict of interest is pretty much illegal anyway, so I

Re: IASA BCP Conflict of Interest Clause?

2004-12-22 Thread Joel M. Halpern
This is a good question. We probably ought to say something. This may be too strong (but I am not sure.) At a minimum, I would expect an IAOC member with such a conflict of interest to recuse themselves from any discussion of the situation. But, as written, this has odd implications. For

Re: IASA BCP Conflict of Interest Clause?

2004-12-22 Thread Harald Tveit Alvestrand
--On onsdag, desember 22, 2004 09:07:22 -0500 Margaret Wasserman [EMAIL PROTECTED] wrote: One question arose when we were writing the original BCP that I haven't seen discussed on the list... Do we need a conflict of interest clause in the BCP? That may be of interest, but we need to be

Re: IASA BCP Conflict of Interest Clause?

2004-12-22 Thread Brian E Carpenter
Margaret Wasserman wrote: One question arose when we were writing the original BCP that I haven't seen discussed on the list... Do we need a conflict of interest clause in the BCP? Something like: The IAD and IAOC may not accept bids from nor establish contracts with members of the IAOC, their

Re: IASA BCP Conflict of Interest Clause?

2004-12-22 Thread Margaret Wasserman
Hi Brian, Margaret Wasserman wrote: One question arose when we were writing the original BCP that I haven't seen discussed on the list... Do we need a conflict of interest clause in the BCP? Something like: The IAD and IAOC may not accept bids from nor establish contracts with members of the

Re: IASA BCP Conflict of Interest Clause?

2004-12-22 Thread Leslie Daigle
Howdy, Margaret Wasserman wrote: I was thinking more of ongoing contracts... For instance, let's say that we contract with Margaret's Meeting Management (MMM -- and no, I am not considering a new career :-)) for our meeting planning. Would it be reasonable for someone who works for MMM to be

Re: IASA BCP Conflict of Interest Clause?

2004-12-22 Thread Stephen Sprunk
Thus spake Leslie Daigle [EMAIL PROTECTED] Margaret Wasserman wrote: I was thinking more of ongoing contracts... For instance, let's say that we contract with Margaret's Meeting Management (MMM -- and no, I am not considering a new career :-)) for our meeting planning. Would it be

Re: IASA BCP Conflict of Interest Clause?

2004-12-22 Thread Margaret Wasserman
I agree with Stephen and others. We could probably just add something in the BCP saying that the IAOC should define and publish an appropriate conflict of interest policy and leave it up to them. Margaret Thus spake Leslie Daigle [EMAIL PROTECTED] Margaret Wasserman wrote: I was thinking

RE: IASA BCP Conflict of Interest Clause?

2004-12-22 Thread Scott W Brim
Stephen Sprunk [EMAIL PROTECTED] on Wednesday, December 22, 2004 13:08: We can require that the IAOC establish rules for dealing with conflicts of interest, and if a member does not follow them (or perhaps does so too frequently) they can be recalled; if that fails, particular decisions can

RE: IASA BCP Conflict of Interest Clause?

2004-12-22 Thread Scott W Brim
Margaret Wasserman on Wednesday, December 22, 2004 13:49: I agree with Stephen and others. We could probably just add something in the BCP saying that the IAOC should define and publish an appropriate conflict of interest policy and leave it up to them. Margaret Can you think of any

RE: IASA BCP Conflict of Interest Clause?

2004-12-22 Thread Harald Tveit Alvestrand
--On onsdag, desember 22, 2004 14:25:08 -0500 Scott W Brim sbrim@cisco.com wrote: Margaret Wasserman on Wednesday, December 22, 2004 13:49: I agree with Stephen and others. We could probably just add something in the BCP saying that the IAOC should define and publish an appropriate conflict

Re: IASA BCP Conflict of Interest Clause?

2004-12-22 Thread avri
I think this is sufficient as well. a. On 22 dec 2004, at 15.22, Harald Tveit Alvestrand wrote: The IAOC will establish and publish rules to handle conflict of interest situations. ___ Ietf mailing list Ietf@ietf.org