Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-26 Thread Dave Crocker
The IAOC has put forward two reasons for having an IETF meeting in South America: Encouraging growing participation will help strengthen the Internet, further encourage participation from those areas that will see the most growth in the coming years, and will help advance the IETF in political

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-26 Thread Juliao Braga
This is the main question with one pragmatic solution proposal in brief, and well justified! Juliao Em 26/05/2013 13:42, Dave Crocker escreveu: If we are serious about wanting more participation from under-represented regions, then let's attack that issue seriously and substantively, rather

Re: WebRTC and emergency communications (Was: Re: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-26 Thread Richard Barnes
Indeed, there has already been some coordination between the groups, going back about a year: http://tools.ietf.org/agenda/84/slides/slides-84-ecrit-0.pdf http://tools.ietf.org/id/draft-aboba-rtcweb-ecrit-00.txt So my read of the situation is much less dire than James's. As I understand it, the

More participation from under-represented regions (was: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-26 Thread SM
At 09:42 26-05-2013, Dave Crocker wrote: I like visiting South America. But IETF meetings do not have tourism as a goal. So yes, I'm sure those who go will enjoy the city; but again, that's not stated purpose of choosing venues. Over a year ago the IAOC [was] pleased to announce the Return

Re: More participation from under-represented regions

2013-05-26 Thread Edwin A. Opare
The elephant in the room is that there hasn't been any discussion about what has been done to get more participation from under-represented regions but nobody has mentioned that. I believe there's the need for a lot more awareness creation about the IETF in the under-represented regions. That

Re: [Recentattendees] IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-26 Thread John C Klensin
--On Sunday, May 26, 2013 15:46 -0400 Ray Pelletier rpellet...@isoc.org wrote: The venues are in Buenos Aires. They meet our requirements for the meeting space, networking, nearby restaurants and bars, hotel room rates in the mid $200 dollar range, nearby alternate hotels at a broad range

Re: More participation from under-represented regions

2013-05-26 Thread SM
Hi Edwin, At 13:59 26-05-2013, Edwin A. Opare wrote: The awareness creation should start at the grassroots level : The Universities!. Train the soon-to-graduate Computer Scientist/Engineer on the values and essence of the IETF and it'll forever be with them even after graduation. To elicit

Re: More participation from under-represented regions

2013-05-26 Thread Randy Presuhn
Hi - Watching this discussion scroll by on my screen, I'm amazed how similar it is to discussions of evangelism in congregations. Two things this religious institution might learn from other religious institutions: (1) need-based evangelism. Outreach efforts are more effective if they

Re: More participation from under-represented regions (was: IETF Meeting in South America)

2013-05-26 Thread Abdussalam Baryun
I support to add the new region, hoping in future Africa gets its chance. IMO, I thought about it from another point of view. After a long time of having IETF meetings mostly in one region (as history of North America region gaining most meetings), the result of that was that IETF participants are

Re: More participation from under-represented regions

2013-05-26 Thread Abdussalam Baryun
Hi SM, There are some from Africa trying to find the way in, but they may not mention it, however, training is not important much to make people participate but the type of training and its period inside organisation not outside. For example, I notice that there was one African participant (not

Re: More participation from under-represented regions

2013-05-26 Thread Juliao Braga
SM, FYI: Inscriptions at IETF 86 [1]: ARIN RIPE APNICAFRINIC LACNIC 671 258 23731 26 54.87% 21.10% 19.38% 2.53%2.13% Inscriptions since IETF 72 to IETF 85. For Year, RIR and Country: http://rfc.pegasus.com.br/ietf.php I think the

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-26 Thread Abdussalam Baryun
I support the ietf-meeting in new regions, and reply as below, On 5/26/13, Dave Crocker d...@dcrocker.net wrote: The IAOC has put forward two reasons for having an IETF meeting in South America: Encouraging growing participation will help strengthen the Internet, further encourage

Re: IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-26 Thread Dave Crocker
Just to make the topic a little more interesting... Google Unable To Keep Paying App Developers In Argentina http://developers.slashdot.org/story/13/05/25/132232/google-unable-to-keep-paying-app-developers-in-argentina Google has sent letters to app developers registered in Argentina

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-26 Thread John Levine
The move appears to be related to new, restrictive regulations the Argentine government has imposed on currency exchanges.' According to the Telegraph, 'The new regulations required anyone wanting to change Argentine pesos into another currency to submit an online request for permission

Re: financial fun with an IETF Meeting in South America

2013-05-26 Thread Juliao Braga
According to the news published for a long time in Brazilian newspapers and magazines, Buenos Aires (a wonderful place!) would not be recommended. But who should tell us about the true cenary would be our Argentine friends. Juliao Em 27/05/2013 01:15, John Levine escreveu: These kinds of

Re: More participation from under-represented regions

2013-05-26 Thread joel jaeggli
On 5/26/13 4:01 PM, SM wrote: Hi Edwin, At 13:59 26-05-2013, Edwin A. Opare wrote: The awareness creation should start at the grassroots level : The Universities!. Train the soon-to-graduate Computer Scientist/Engineer on the values and essence of the IETF and it'll forever be with them even

Issues in wider geographic participation

2013-05-26 Thread John Levine
I think this is a summary of the issues people have mentioned that discourage participation from LDCs, in rough order of importance. * People aren't aware the IETF exists, or what it does, or that it has an open participation model * People don't read and write English well enough to be