Re: What is at stake?

2002-01-25 Thread Einar Stefferud
+ At 14:10 -0800 24/01/02, Ed Gerck wrote: Keith Moore wrote: There have now been multiple postings that explained how reality was substantially different than you have been claiming. As a consequence, actual history does not support your

REMINDER: revision to RFC2727 - NOMCOM

2002-01-25 Thread James M Galvin
I just wanted to call your attention to the recently announced proposed revision: Title : IAB and IESG Selection, Confirmation, and Recall Process: Operation of the Nominating and Recall Comittees Filename:

Re: REMINDER: revision to RFC2727 - NOMCOM

2002-01-25 Thread Dave Crocker
At 10:34 AM 1/25/2002 -0500, James M Galvin wrote: I just wanted to call your attention to the recently announced proposed revision: Perhaps the best time for pursuing revisions to this document is immediately after the nomcom has done it job. That way you will have a pool of very fresh

Re: REMINDER: revision to RFC2727 - NOMCOM

2002-01-25 Thread Paul Hoffman / IMC
At 8:50 AM -0800 1/25/02, Dave Crocker wrote: At 10:34 AM 1/25/2002 -0500, James M Galvin wrote: I just wanted to call your attention to the recently announced proposed revision: Perhaps the best time for pursuing revisions to this document is immediately after the nomcom has done it job. That

Re: Revision to RFC2727 - NOMCOM

2002-01-25 Thread Eric Brunner-Williams in Portland Maine
James, I'm going to differ with my learned colleges Dave and Paul. There may be points of 2727 and draft 2727bis that have the potential to benefit from deference until the current nomcom has done its job, but from my reading not all of them fall into that bin. In particular, I don't see how

Re: REMINDER: revision to RFC2727 - NOMCOM

2002-01-25 Thread James M Galvin
Two things in response to the issue of waiting to deal with the revised NOMCOM document. First, as a practical matter, I'm not inclined to believe there's a significant issue. If the timetable as specified in RFC2727 is completed on schedule, the NOMCOM will be done in less than 3 weeks. Even