VoIP regulation... Japan versus USA approaches (RE: Masataka Ohta, Simon)

2003-09-03 Thread Dan Kolis
Masataka Ohta and/or Simon said: You should, at least, distinguish VoIP as a telephone network and the Internet telephony. In Japan, TAs to connect the Internet and POTS telephone devices are rapidly replacing the telephone network including VoIP ones. a. VoIP is telephony and should be regulated.

RE: VoIP regulation... Japan versus USA approaches (RE: Masataka Ohta, Simon)

2003-09-03 Thread Robert . Shaw
I am curious how Japan does this, but the island size and density makes the whole argument different to some extent. So, how's it work under the wise rule of NHK/MTT ??? That'd be MPHPT at http://www.soumu.go.jp/ see http://www.itu.int/osg/spu/newslog/2003/09/03.html#a172, particularly the

RE: VoIP regulation... Japan versus USA approaches (RE: Masataka Ohta, Simon)

2003-09-03 Thread Christian de Larrinaga
Many countries have moved beyond the regulatory debates that characterize the US very-much sector-specific regulatory framework. There are a number of indications the landscape is changing rapidly in the US too (see http://www.itu.int/osg/spu/newslog/categories/voip/2003/08/22. html#a159)

RE: VoIP regulation... Japan versus USA approaches (RE: Masataka Ohta, Simon)

2003-09-03 Thread Robert . Shaw
you mean that current telecoms regulations are passed their sell by date anyway and serve as trade protectionism for a fast reducing minority of vested interests? Christian No, on the contrary. For example, if it hadn't been for proactive regulatory intervention in local loop

Re: VoIP regulation... Japan versus USA approaches (RE: Masataka Ohta, Simon)

2003-09-03 Thread S Woodside
Robert, thanks for the links. Very educational. Indeed is the ITU definition: IP telephony is used as a generic term for the transmission of voice using IP technology. IP telephony can be broadly classified as configurations using closed-bandwidth IP networks or IP networks with

Re: VoIP regulation... Japan versus USA approaches (RE: Masataka Ohta,Simon)

2003-09-03 Thread Masataka Ohta
Simon; Internet Telephony another paradox. How can the public internet possibly support telephony? We have as axiomatic the edge-to-edge principle which guarantees that the person at the other end may not have UPS power supply. This is a DESIGN GOAL of the internet, hence, the

Re: VoIP regulation... Japan versus USA approaches (RE: Masataka Ohta,Simon)

2003-09-03 Thread Masataka Ohta
Bob; I am curious how Japan does this, but the island size and density makes the whole argument different to some extent. So, how's it work under the wise rule of NHK/MTT ??? That'd be MPHPT at http://www.soumu.go.jp/ Though cabinet set a wise strategy, MPHPT has no idea on what is