Re: [Ifeffit] Asymmetric error bars in IFeffit

2010-10-22 Thread Matthew Marcus
Some quantities, such as effective coordination numbers, are roughly linear in 1/size, so there's an argument for doing the coordinate transformation size-1/size. If you do that, then be sure to make things functions of abs(u) where u==1/size, because u0 is unphysical. Doing it this way also

Re: [Ifeffit] Asymmetric error bars in IFeffit

2010-10-22 Thread Frenkel, Anatoly
On a related subject, now I understand why we use the concept of chemical transferability of amplitudes and phases by recycling the same FEFF path for different systems. The true reason is historic: back then it took one hour for one FEFF calculation Anatoly

Re: [Ifeffit] Asymmetric error bars in IFeffit

2010-10-22 Thread Matthew Marcus
Another reason, from my point of view, is that FEFF wasn't accurate enough to use on its own without references. Also, it still can be argued that the process of data reduction and filtering produces distortions which aren't captured by using FEFF alone. Further, if one is comparing very

Re: [Ifeffit] Asymmetric error bars in IFeffit

2010-10-22 Thread Frenkel, Anatoly
Matthew, if you relied on FEFF as one part of the complex calculation, where the other part was the experimentally extracted one, you could've as well done everything with just FEFF. Why didn't you? A. From: ifeffit-boun...@millenia.cars.aps.anl.gov