Hi Bruce (and Ifeffiteers),
I'm not positive this is a bug--maybe I'm just misunderstanding how
the features are supposed to work. (It wouldn't be the first time!)
In Athena 0.8.061 on a Mac running OS 10.5.8, I tried the following (I
tried it in more than one project, to make sure it's not an
intermittent bug):
--Under Edit Preferences/Merge/Merge_Weight, choose "n" and apply to
future sessions
--Close Athena and reopen
--Open a project
--Mark two data sets.
--Change the "importance" of one of them.
--Under the merge menu, choose "weight by importance."
--Under the merge menu, "merge marked data in chi(k)"
The result for me is that the merged file ignores the importance I've
assigned. I've also tried it in mu(E), with the same result.
It seems that perhaps the "n" value in the preferences overrides the
"weight by importance" option in the menu? If so, that's not the way I
expect preferences and menu options to interact.
Trying it with applying the "n" only to the current session also has
an interesting behavior, although not necessarily the "wrong" one: it
seems to just change the radio button in the menu. Also, if I change
the radio button in the menu directly, the option under Preferences
changes to match. For the current session, I can understand the
argument that this is a reasonable behavior. But it is likely to cause
confusion if a user changes it in the menu and then tries to use the
preferences to check what the future sessions value is set to--if they
haven't previously changed the preferences directly during the
session, they might naturally assume that the value there is the value
for future sessions, but in reality it just represents the most recent
menu choice they made, and could be different in a future session.
My suggested fix to both issues: the preferences should control what
value the radio button takes on when Athena is first opened, and
changes to the preferences should cause an immediate change to the
status of the radio button. Subsequent changes to the radio button
should not change the value under the preferences. And the behavior of
the merge function should always reflect the current value of the
radio button.
--Scott Calvin
Sarah Lawrence College
_______________________________________________
Ifeffit mailing list
Ifeffit@millenia.cars.aps.anl.gov
http://millenia.cars.aps.anl.gov/mailman/listinfo/ifeffit
