Hi, NKA mapper:
Thank you for preparing this import and writing the wiki.
I haven't checked the data itself, but a have a few observations:
In the section background, under "Link to permission" you say 22 March
2017, while you talk of 2018 elsewhere. I guess it's just a typo.
For the tagging, there are a set of them that need to be documented:
sortere:ref=* -> I think it should be documented in a wiki for itself,
including its purpose (helping in updating data in the future).
For the recycling:xxx tags, I guess it would be nice to propose the not
documented ones in the tagging list. These are the tags where I see
possible issues (I may have missed the point with some of them, of course):
recycling:cars -> I don't see it documented in any wiki.
recycling:cardboard -> Shouldn't recycling:cardboard (not documented) be
changed to recycling:chipboard (documented)? It looks the same kind of
stuff.
recycling:refund_bottles -> I don't see it documented in any wiki.
recycling:second_hand -> I don't see it documented in any wiki.
recycling:impregnated_wood -> I don't see it documented in any wiki.
recycling:window_glass -> I don't see it documented in any wiki, but
that stuff is included in recycling:glass
recycling:explosives -> I don't see it documented in any wiki.
recycling:small_appliance -> It's recycling:small_appliances, not
recycling:small_appliance
recycling:flammable_waste -> I don't see it documented in any wiki.
Couldn't it be included in recycling:hazardous_waste?
recycling:clean_waste -> I don't see it documented in any wiki.
recycling:inert_waste -> I don't see it documented in any wiki. It seems
to me too open. Maybe rubble?
recycling:compost -> Not documented, but it might be
recycling:garden_waste...
recycling:asbestos -> Asbestos is part of recycling:hazardous_waste.
It's not documented anyway.
recycling:marine_debris -> I don't see it documented in any wiki.
recycling:boats -> I don't see it documented in any wiki.
As for the changeset tags:
1) description=* should be changed to comment*. To make it more
descriptive, I would set the comment like this (or equivalent):
comment=Norway Sortere.no recycling centres and containers
2) I would add the following two tags:
type=import
url=https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Import/Catalogue/Recycling_Import_Norway
I hope you find my comments useful.
Cheers,
Rafael.
On 06/04/18 17:06, NKA mapper wrote:
Here is an import plan for recycling containers and centres in Norway
for your review:
https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Import/Catalogue/Recycling_Import_Norway
A difficulty when planning this import has been the lack of definitions
and descriptions at amenity=recycling
<https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/wiki/Tag:amenity=recycling> for tagging
the various materials. That list could also benefit from introducing a
certain hierarchy and structure, I think, because there is currently a
mix of detailed material types and group of materials (both of which are
useful).
I am looking forward to your comments to the plan.
/NKA
_______________________________________________
Imports mailing list
Imports@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/imports
_______________________________________________
Imports mailing list
Imports@openstreetmap.org
https://lists.openstreetmap.org/listinfo/imports
