[Ipmitool-devel] SOL thru port forwarding

2011-12-30 Thread Martin Hamant
Hi !!! I have a BMC configured with a local IP adress (192.168.X.X) listening on default port (623). I want to access it from the outside world. For that I have set a port forwarding rules on the router to the port 623 of this local IP. every ipmitool commands works well BUT not SOL. # ipmit

Re: [Ipmitool-devel] SOL thru port forwarding

2011-12-30 Thread Martin Hamant
Hi Hank, Thanks for you reply, but I'm still not sure we speak about the same thing :/ I also have discovered in ipmi_sol.c / ipmitool : (...) /* NOTE: the spec does allow for SOL traffic to be sent on * a different port. we do not yet support that feature. */ if (intf->session-

Re: [Ipmitool-devel] SOL thru port forwarding

2011-12-30 Thread Hank Bruning
The RMCP server can use any UDP port it wants to for a SOL session. Some implementations use port 623. If you have more than two SOL sessions open on a single RMCP server at least one will be on a port other than 623. Each of the SOL sessions may be encrypted differently using separate cipher suite

Re: [Ipmitool-devel] SOL thru port forwarding

2011-12-30 Thread Al Chu
I think this is what Hank is talking about. SOL connects at port 623, but it may communicate over a different port later in the session. However, ipmitool doesn't support communication over any port other than 623. So if SOL works for you w/o port forwarding, then this isn't your issue. Al On

Re: [Ipmitool-devel] SOL thru port forwarding

2011-12-30 Thread Martin Hamant
I'm lost. Let me formulate what I understand: ipmitool is a tool to connect to any (most?) baseboard management controller, to get/set system settings. ipmitool with default settings connects on port 623/UDP This was the easiest part :D And to this point all is going well WITH or without PNAT (

Re: [Ipmitool-devel] SOL thru port forwarding

2011-12-30 Thread Andy Cress
Martin, Have you established that SOL works locally (without the port forwarding)? This would rule out a firmware bug or firmware configuration issue. Andy -- Ridiculously easy VDI. With Citrix VDI-in-a-Box, you don't