Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-04-14 Thread Gert Doering
Hi, On Mon, Apr 13, 2015 at 11:31:57PM +0200, Jens Link wrote: I told my first customer about Y2k in 1980. He called last week. If anyone of you speaks Cobol the customer is paying $large_amount per hour for fixing his problems. With IPv6 there is no fixed date but I will happen too.

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-04-14 Thread Tim Chown
On 14 Apr 2015, at 08:42, Gert Doering g...@space.net wrote: Hi, On Mon, Apr 13, 2015 at 11:31:57PM +0200, Jens Link wrote: I told my first customer about Y2k in 1980. He called last week. If anyone of you speaks Cobol the customer is paying $large_amount per hour for fixing his

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-04-13 Thread Benedikt Stockebrand
Hi Phil and list, Phil Mayers p.may...@imperial.ac.uk writes: On 13/04/15 09:55, Benedikt Stockebrand wrote: Which is a major effort in some environments because---contrary to what Nick wrote---pretty much anyone involved needs to be familiarized with IPv6. The reason here is that if there

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-04-13 Thread Jens Link
Jens Hoffmann j...@bofh.de writes: PS: SCNR: English is not part of the unions description of my job. They didn't have a job. They trained to get one. Jens -- | Foelderichstr. 40 | 13595 Berlin, Germany

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-04-13 Thread Jens Link
Jared Mauch ja...@puck.nether.net writes: You have at least two addresses to configure, which leads to two DNS records, two services to be monitored, more firewall rules, ... And in the end more things to document. This sure is true in an environment where humans are still the gating

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-04-13 Thread Jens Link
Benedikt Stockebrand b...@stepladder-it.com writes: And yes, back in 95 there were allegedly people testing the hardware they bought for being year 2000 compliant:-) Back in '99 my employer send me to an Oracle training. I do not remember much about Oracle but I do remember one quote from the

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-04-13 Thread Jens Link
Ted Mittelstaedt t...@ipinc.net writes: sorry for the delayed answer. I was quite busy doing non IPv6 stuff ;-) Kind of like you drafted Billy Joe Bob from Hayseed to troubleshoot your 2015 Chevy Volt and it extended the time troubleshooting because he's still looking for the carburetor.

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-04-13 Thread Jens Hoffmann
-BEGIN PGP SIGNED MESSAGE- Hash: SHA1 Hi, Am 13.04.15 um 22:51 schrieb Jens Link: I think the worst thing I've said was learn enough english to understand the documentation. Das ist nicht Teil der tariflichen Arbeitsplatzbeschreibung. Cheers, Jens PS: SCNR: English is not part

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-04-13 Thread Benedikt Stockebrand
Hi Andy and list, Andy Davidson a...@nosignal.org writes: This is a strange question, but I think as a consultant I would want to design a rollout methodology that made that overhead (cost) as close to zero for your customer as possible. that depends; in some cases you're far more interested

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-04-13 Thread Phil Mayers
On 11/04/15 10:27, Nick Hilliard wrote: Uh, lemme just drop this in here: http://imgur.com/AYbpRG2 ;o) The problem with stage 4 is that it requires that the expertise garnered by the initial deployment team is spread throughout the rest of the company, ranging from product development to

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-04-13 Thread Phil Mayers
On 13/04/15 09:55, Benedikt Stockebrand wrote: Which is a major effort in some environments because---contrary to what Nick wrote---pretty much anyone involved needs to be familiarized with IPv6. The reason here is that if there is any problem once IPv6 is enabled anywhere, then *all* people

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-04-12 Thread S.P.Zeidler
Thus wrote Andy Davidson (a...@nosignal.org): Stage one - write v6 support requirements into RFP for equipment before you plan to turn it on. Ideally this will be based on document RIPE-554 and be part of your buying process already (and have been in this process for at least the last

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-04-11 Thread Nick Hilliard
On 10/04/2015 21:36, Andy Davidson wrote: Stage one - [...] Stage two - [...] Stage three - [...] Stage four - utilise your new training and v6 capable edge to roll out NEW services dual-stack. The incremental cost of adding v6 support to a NEW rollout when you have to do a bunch of work

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-04-10 Thread Andy Davidson
On 26 Mar 2015, at 09:04, BERENGUER Christophe christophe.bereng...@solucom.fr wrote: For a client, I would like to estimate the work overload for IT operations team to deploy IPv6 dual stack and for day to day operations. On the internet, I have found an estimation around 20% of work

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-04-04 Thread Mikael Abrahamsson
On Fri, 3 Apr 2015, Ted Mittelstaedt wrote: normal hardware refresh cycles is something the Fortune 1000 have. It's a nice concept but not one universally adopted by everyone else in the real world. Another one of these is hardware service contracts That's not universally adopted, either.

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-04-04 Thread Ted Mittelstaedt
The industrial machine was only used as an example to keep the fools from replying why would anyone want to run Windows XP anymore There are still a lot of orgs that run it and run Chrome on it. And a simple registry tweak gets you all of the patches that MS released for Windows Embedded for

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-04-04 Thread Jussi Peltola
I know plenty of industrial machines that speak the pre-IP Microsoft protocols to get G code files into them. Some also depend on the clock rate of their 486 CPU for timing. Some have a C compiler on disk that was used to develop the control software they run. IPv6-enabling these devices is

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-04-03 Thread Ted Mittelstaedt
All of this assumes normal hardware refresh cycles That may be the case for ordinary office users but I got a million dollar asphalt kiln attached to a Windows 98 controller with a serial port that says otherwise. Just wanting to point out that normal hardware refresh cycles more often

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-03-27 Thread Seth Mos
Op 27 mrt. 2015, om 00:23 heeft Brian E Carpenter brian.e.carpen...@gmail.com het volgende geschreven: On 26/03/2015 22:04, BERENGUER Christophe wrote: Hello everybody, I work for a consulting firm. For a client, I would like to estimate the work overload for IT operations team

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-03-27 Thread Ted Mittelstaedt
Without a detailed look at the client this kind of question falls in the realm of my kid's story problems in her mathematics book - pretty sounding things that are utterly divorced from reality. I will just say this, however: If you do NOT deploy IPv6 then yes it will save labor. Depending

RE: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-03-27 Thread BERENGUER Christophe
+christophe.berenguer=solucom...@lists.cluenet.de ipv6-ops-bounces+christophe.berenguer=solucom...@lists.cluenet.de de la part de Ted Mittelstaedt t...@ipinc.net Envoyé : vendredi 27 mars 2015 09:27 À : ipv6-ops@lists.cluenet.de Objet : Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team Without a detailed look

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-03-27 Thread Brian E Carpenter
The 20% figure is based on an IETF document Which one? We can fix that if people think it's wrong. (This comes just too late for yesterday's v6ops meeting at the IETF in Dallas.) Regards Brian

RE: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-03-27 Thread BERENGUER Christophe
Cedex De : Brian E Carpenter brian.e.carpen...@gmail.com Envoyé : vendredi 27 mars 2015 13:21 À : BERENGUER Christophe Cc : Ted Mittelstaedt; ipv6-ops@lists.cluenet.de Objet : Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team The 20% figure is based on an IETF

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-03-27 Thread Phil Mayers
On 26/03/15 09:04, BERENGUER Christophe wrote: Hello everybody, I work for a consulting firm. For a client, I would like to estimate the work overload for IT operations team to deploy IPv6 dual stack and for day to day operations. On the internet, I have found an estimation around 20% of

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-03-27 Thread Brian E Carpenter
2015 13:21 À : BERENGUER Christophe Cc : Ted Mittelstaedt; ipv6-ops@lists.cluenet.de Objet : Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team The 20% figure is based on an IETF document Which one? We can fix that if people think it's wrong. (This comes just too late for yesterday's v6ops meeting

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-03-27 Thread Ted Mittelstaedt
I don't think that having things in the mix extends troubleshooting. My experience is that problems generally fall into 2 buckets: 1) Textbook ones (mistyped IP address, overload that's readily visible if they had looked at the reports, or like you said full hard disk) The time-suck in

Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-03-26 Thread BERENGUER Christophe
Hello everybody, I work for a consulting firm. For a client, I would like to estimate the work overload for IT operations team to deploy IPv6 dual stack and for day to day operations. On the internet, I have found an estimation around 20% of work overload for the run phase. But if you have

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-03-26 Thread John Mann
Hi, Deployment work overload could be 5%. For deployment of dual stack, you should minimise work overload by: - taking advantage of normal refresh cycles and bundle enabling of dual stack into the refresh or deployment of new management systems, procedures, and services - picking low hanging

Re: Cost of IPv6 for IT operations team

2015-03-26 Thread Brian E Carpenter
On 26/03/2015 22:04, BERENGUER Christophe wrote: Hello everybody, I work for a consulting firm. For a client, I would like to estimate the work overload for IT operations team to deploy IPv6 dual stack and for day to day operations. On the internet, I have found an estimation