[isabelle-dev] position of Hilbert_Choice in the HOL theory hierarchy

2007-09-14 Thread Christian Urban
Lawrence Paulson writes: Florian has suggested making sledgehammer available earlier in the construction of Main, before PreList at least. This could be useful to developers. However, it requires Hilbert_Choice, which must also be introduced earlier. We previously put some effort

[isabelle-dev] position of Hilbert_Choice in the HOL theory hierarchy

2007-09-14 Thread Florian Haftmann
Florian has suggested making sledgehammer available earlier in the construction of Main, before PreList at least. This could be useful to developers. However, it requires Hilbert_Choice, which must also be introduced earlier. A PreList-Sledgehammer would be a nice thing to have, but it

[isabelle-dev] position of Hilbert_Choice in the HOL theory hierarchy

2007-09-14 Thread Lawrence Paulson
It needs at least Hilbert_Choice. It could go before Datatype. Some details need to be worked out to ensure that all theorems in Main.thy get converted to clause form. Larry On 14 Sep 2007, at 14:46, Florian Haftmann wrote: A PreList-Sledgehammer would be a nice thing to have, but it is not

[isabelle-dev] position of Hilbert_Choice in the HOL theory hierarchy

2007-09-14 Thread Florian Haftmann
Lawrence Paulson wrote: It needs at least Hilbert_Choice. It could go before Datatype. Some details need to be worked out to ensure that all theorems in Main.thy get converted to clause form. I must confess that I have lost track now. Does only the skolemization depend on Hilbert-Choice, or

[isabelle-dev] position of Hilbert_Choice in the HOL theory hierarchy

2007-09-14 Thread Makarius
On Fri, 14 Sep 2007, Stefan Berghofer wrote: For those members of the list who have not followed the discussion about this issue a few years ago, let me cite what Larry wrote about it: I think it would be quite easy to do, and sensible (ZF has always been that way). [...] If