Re: [josm-dev] Source code formatting template?

2008-08-27 Thread GeoJ
Frederik Ramm wrote: Would you be able to supply such a style sheet that approximately matches the current formatting (as far as this is at all discernible)? Of course they are not all discernible - I would be surprised if not. I checked a small randomly chosen file set and compared the

Re: [josm-dev] Source code formatting template?

2008-08-27 Thread Frederik Ramm
Hi, 1. Indentation: space vs. tab I'd go for spaces always. 2. Maximum line length: A large number of files do contain very lengthy lines, mostly for defining strings with display messages. Other files use a maximum line length of ap. 100-140 characters (which is my favorite setting,

Re: [josm-dev] Source code formatting template?

2008-08-27 Thread GeoJ
Frederik Ramm wrote: Generally I'd avoid long lines but we must take care not to make life difficult for translators. Does it pose a problem for translation if one says tr(some + long + message) instead of tr(some long message) As tr() is a static function that is called at

Re: [josm-dev] Source code formatting template?

2008-08-27 Thread Frederik Ramm
Hi, As tr() is a static function that is called at runtime this should not make any difference. I am unsure how the process that extracts the string constants to be translated works. It can't possibly *execute* every branch of code that contains a tr()? But as I said, not my core competency

Re: [josm-dev] Source code formatting template?

2008-08-27 Thread Dirk Stöcker
On Wed, 27 Aug 2008, Frederik Ramm wrote: As tr() is a static function that is called at runtime this should not make any difference. No. The translations are extracted from the sources, so the source design is important. You can't use whatever methods to join a string, as these will not be

Re: [josm-dev] Source code formatting template?

2008-08-26 Thread Frederik Ramm
Hi, That would be avoidable if we could agree to a common source code formatting standard (in form of an style sheet file as it it used e.g. by Eclipse). Then every body would only have to apply the common source code formatter on the source before checking in /creating a patch. Would you

[josm-dev] Source code formatting template?

2008-08-25 Thread GeoJ
Petr Nejedly wrote: It would be fine if Jörg cold separate the real functional patch from all the unrelated formatting changes. It is quite hard to follow the semantics of the change in all the noise... That would be avoidable if we could agree to a common source code formatting standard (in