Re: [julia-users] I'd like to see something like the Rust platform proposal in the Julia ecosystem

2016-08-01 Thread 'Tobias Knopp' via julia-users
I think that Steven has a point here. Technically we have all in place and Tims "Reexport" snipped is indeed the solution for creating Matlab like toolboxes. Its quite interesting that nobody has yet done such a metapackage. Maybe its because those users knowing the packages like the

Re: [julia-users] I'd like to see something like the Rust platform proposal in the Julia ecosystem

2016-08-01 Thread Steven Sagaert
When I say "work well together" I don't just mean that their versions technically work together without errors, but also that they match stylistically and that the datastructures that they expect as input/output match so that no excessive translation and/or copying of data is needed which is

Re: [julia-users] I'd like to see something like the Rust platform proposal in the Julia ecosystem

2016-08-01 Thread Steven Sagaert
I think the most important part of it is the idea of having a second (beyond the standard lib that comes with the runtime) larger, optional layer of curated libs that are known to work together. That together with the metapackage idea for easy inclusion ( maybe with possible overrides as in

Re: [julia-users] I'd like to see something like the Rust platform proposal in the Julia ecosystem

2016-08-01 Thread Stefan Karpinski
There's a fair amount of discussion of the Rust Platform proposal over here: https://internals.rust-lang.org/t/proposal-the-rust-platform/3745 In short there's a lack of agreement to this in Rust. Moreover, in Rust, different versions of libraries are much more closely locked to each other,

Re: [julia-users] I'd like to see something like the Rust platform proposal in the Julia ecosystem

2016-08-01 Thread Tony Kelman
The vision I personally have for this would be something more like SUSE Studio (https://susestudio.com/) where it's just a few clicks, or a configuration file in the build system, that could give you a set of default-installed packages of your choosing, and make installers for your own custom

Re: [julia-users] I'd like to see something like the Rust platform proposal in the Julia ecosystem

2016-08-01 Thread Tim Holy
module MyMetaPackage using Reexport @reexport using PackageA @reexport using PackageB ... end Best. --Tim On Monday, August 1, 2016 1:48:47 AM CDT Steven Sagaert wrote: > is more than just a webpage with a list of packages... for starters the > concept of metapackage. > > On Monday, August

Re: [julia-users] I'd like to see something like the Rust platform proposal in the Julia ecosystem

2016-08-01 Thread Steven Sagaert
is more than just a webpage with a list of packages... for starters the concept of metapackage. On Monday, August 1, 2016 at 10:25:33 AM UTC+2, Tamas Papp wrote: > > Maybe you already know about it, but there is a curated list of packages > at https://github.com/svaksha/Julia.jl > > On Mon,

Re: [julia-users] I'd like to see something like the Rust platform proposal in the Julia ecosystem

2016-08-01 Thread Tamas Papp
Maybe you already know about it, but there is a curated list of packages at https://github.com/svaksha/Julia.jl On Mon, Aug 01 2016, Steven Sagaert wrote: > see https://aturon.github.io/blog/2016/07/27/rust-platform/