I'm happy with KClock now, FWIW. I'm going to start sending merge
requests for some of the little tiny UI things I notice that I don't
think are worth prolonging KDEReview over.
Nate
On 2/2/23 21:11, Devin wrote:
Hi everyone,
Is there any feedback left for KClock? If not, I will consider it to
have passed kdereview.
Thanks,
Devin
On Fri, Dec 30, 2022 at 2:27 AM Justin <justin.zo...@gmail.com> wrote:
Thanks for the quick reply Albert. I'm not a developer but I've gone
over much of the comments from previous:
Tested on 22.11
> New Timer doesn't work? Ah it's because it needs kclockd running for
that, would it be very hard to give a warning if it isn't running?
Seems kclockd is now running automatically. If it is not automatically
running that would (in my opinion) be a packaging issue on the distro side.
> Is that kirigamiaddons thing released? Seems to be the reason i can't
add new Alarms
Kirigami Addons has now passed KDE review and has stable releases
> Not an expert in UI but for stopwatch having Start/Pause on the top
left feels a bit unnatural, maybe would make sense swapping reset and
Start? Ask the VDG i guess.
In the version I'm running it's centered nicely and I think works well.
If you can check this against latest git master to confirm the UI is
still the same.
> Also in stopwatch for me it'd make a lot of sense if pressing the
time starts/pauses, what do you think?
This is functioning now.
> Silence Alarm After shows an horizontal scrollbar that doesn't to be
very useful https://i.imgur.com/7O8DBJc.png
This is now called Ring Duration and has no horizontal scroll bar even
at the minimum window width.
> It's even worse in Alarm Snooze Length where it goes over existing text
Same as above, now fixed.
> You're missing Messages.sh in kclockd
I see this now in the kclockd folder
> Please check i18n in your qml files, these seem like need i18n
> ...
Lots of this i18n stuff appears to have been moved and will need a new
review
Justin
On 30/12/22 20:44, Albert Astals Cid wrote:
El divendres, 30 de desembre de 2022, a les 8:46:56 (CET), Justin va escriure:
Hey Team,
This was last posted about on October 18 2021. I looked at the three
items that were needed for kirigami-addons:
* Missing is REUSE compliance:
https://invent.kde.org/libraries/kirigami-addons/-/merge_requests/13
* Hanyoung is working on a better time picker:
https://invent.kde.org/libraries/kirigami-addons/-/merge_requests/17
* And Clau is working on a better date picker:
https://invent.kde.org/libraries/kirigami-addons/-/merge_requests/20
They have all now been merged. Can we resume the review on
kirigami-addons so we can continue on kclock?
Thanks everyone and have a enjoyable and safe holiday!
I gave a long list of comments back in the day that were never answered, do
that first and maybe i give it another look.
Cheers,
Albert
Justin
