Re: Usefulness of Subject-header of git commit mails

2011-01-28 Thread Parker Coates
On Fri, Jan 28, 2011 at 11:42, Andreas Hartmetz wrote: On Monday 24 January 2011 00:13:26 Eike Hein wrote: Yep - for the benefit of those who aren't used to the git jargon (sorry for that), in git the convention is to for- mat the commit message like this: single line of about 50 chars,

Re: Usefulness of Subject-header of git commit mails

2011-01-24 Thread Boudewijn Rempt
On Sunday 23 January 2011, Milian Wolff wrote: But probably my problem is that I only work on semi-large repositories like KDevelop/KDevplatform/Kate. There I'm interested in *everything* that goes on. In Calligra you have only one big repo for all the apps, correct? Here I indeed can

Re: Usefulness of Subject-header of git commit mails

2011-01-23 Thread Ivan Čukić
Example: [KDevPlatform] fafd165: Don't completely ignore the retrieved top-context For me, this is more useful, so +1 Maybe adding a keyword 'commit' before the short hash like this [KDevPlatform] Commit fafd165: Don't completely ignore the retrieved top-context -- Cheerio, Ivan -- While

Re: Usefulness of Subject-header of git commit mails

2011-01-23 Thread Milian Wolff
Boudewijn Rempt, 23.01.2011: On Sunday 23 January 2011, Milian Wolff wrote: Hey all, I've brought this discussion to the sysadmins recently and they asked me to ask for feedback here. So there it goes: Recently, the format of the subject of git commit emails was adapted to use the

Re: Usefulness of Subject-header of git commit mails

2011-01-23 Thread Eike Hein
On 1/23/2011 9:30 PM, Milian Wolff wrote: What was broken? Nothing as far as Commitfilter is concerned. Commitfilter actually acts on the X-Commit-Directories headers, not the mail subject. This header was actually somewhat broken in the old mails, it has been fixed now as part of the hooks

Re: Usefulness of Subject-header of git commit mails

2011-01-23 Thread Milian Wolff
Eike Hein, 23.01.2011: On 1/23/2011 9:30 PM, Milian Wolff wrote: What was broken? Nothing as far as Commitfilter is concerned. Commitfilter actually acts on the X-Commit-Directories headers, not the mail subject. This header was actually somewhat broken in the old mails, it has been fixed

Re: Usefulness of Subject-header of git commit mails

2011-01-23 Thread Milian Wolff
Eike Hein, 23.01.2011: @sysadmins: would it be possible to change the format for some repos or is this not possible? I.e. leave the decision to the project maintainers? Would you be OK with this hybrid format that we discussed a few days ago: [repo sans git/branch*] common root path:

Re: Usefulness of Subject-header of git commit mails

2011-01-23 Thread Allan Sandfeld Jensen
On Sunday 23 January 2011, Eike Hein wrote: @sysadmins: would it be possible to change the format for some repos or is this not possible? I.e. leave the decision to the project maintainers? Would you be OK with this hybrid format that we discussed a few days ago: [repo sans

Re: Usefulness of Subject-header of git commit mails

2011-01-23 Thread Tom Albers
- Oorspronkelijk bericht - On 1/23/2011 9:30 PM, Milian Wolff wrote: What was broken? Nothing as far as Commitfilter is concerned. Commitfilter actually acts on the X-Commit-Directories headers, not the mail subject. This header was actually somewhat broken in the old mails, it has