D12992: New elisa icon

ndavis added a comment. icons/apps/22/elisa.svg does not apply cleanly. Not sure why. REPOSITORY R266 Breeze Icons REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D12992 To: lshoravi, #vdg, ngraham, #elisa Cc: trickyricky26, ndavis, KonqiDragon, abetts, paullesur, januz, mgallien, alex-l,

D12992: New elisa icon

ngraham added a subscriber: trickyricky26. ngraham added a comment. @abetts has been inactive recently; probably needs @lshoravi or @ndavis or @trickyricky26 to take over. REPOSITORY R266 Breeze Icons REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D12992 To: lshoravi, #vdg, ngraham,

D12992: New elisa icon

mgallien added a comment. In D12992#533180 , @lshoravi wrote: > Bumping @abetts Thanks for keeping this on your todo list. This is very much appreciated. I am trying to move forward the process of having Elisa published on Windows

D12992: New elisa icon

lshoravi added a comment. Bumping @abetts REPOSITORY R266 Breeze Icons REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D12992 To: lshoravi, #vdg, ngraham, #elisa Cc: ndavis, KonqiDragon, abetts, paullesur, januz, mgallien, alex-l, andreask, kde-frameworks-devel, mfraser, mnesbitt,

D12992: New elisa icon

ndavis added a comment. In D12992#503172 , @KonqiDragon wrote: > In D12992#269399 , @abetts wrote: > > > I think we are trying hard to accommodate and the elements are not lending themselves to

D12992: New elisa icon

KonqiDragon added a comment. In D12992#269399 , @abetts wrote: > I think we are trying hard to accommodate and the elements are not lending themselves to turn them into an E with some musical tones. I reviewed a few music sheets looking for

D12992: New elisa icon

lshoravi added a comment. I believe we'll need @abetts .svg file- I can't seem to find it. REPOSITORY R266 Breeze Icons REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D12992 To: lshoravi, #vdg, ngraham, #elisa Cc: abetts, paullesur, januz, mgallien, alex-l, andreask, kde-frameworks-devel,

D12992: New elisa icon

mgallien added a comment. In D12992#486880 , @lshoravi wrote: > Using @abetts prototype: No blockers, incorporating the given teal and green colours given by mgallien is TODO. > > Otherwise, the blocker would be to find what visual profile

D12992: New elisa icon

lshoravi added a comment. Using @abetts prototype: No blockers, incorporating the given teal and green colours given by mgallien is TODO. Otherwise, the blocker would be to find what visual profile Elisa has so that we can work around that. REPOSITORY R266 Breeze Icons REVISION

D12992: New elisa icon

ngraham added a comment. There is no timeframe. :) I was just hoping this doesn't get abandoned, because it looks rally nice. What are the remaining blockers, currently? REPOSITORY R266 Breeze Icons REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D12992 To: lshoravi, #vdg, ngraham,

D12992: New elisa icon

lshoravi added a comment. Doable! What timeframe are we thinking? REPOSITORY R266 Breeze Icons REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D12992 To: lshoravi, #vdg, ngraham, #elisa Cc: abetts, paullesur, januz, mgallien, alex-l, andreask, kde-frameworks-devel, mnesbitt, LeGast00n,

D12992: New elisa icon

ngraham added a comment. @lshoravi ping! Any chance we can finish up work on this icon and get it in? REPOSITORY R266 Breeze Icons REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D12992 To: lshoravi, #vdg, ngraham, #elisa Cc: abetts, paullesur, januz, mgallien, alex-l, andreask,

D12992: New elisa icon

mgallien added a comment. In D12992#269849 , @abetts wrote: > In D12992#269803 , @lshoravi wrote: > > > @abetts Yes, I've been concepting a little on different ideas but not really coming anywhere

D12992: New elisa icon

ngraham added a comment. I like it! REPOSITORY R266 Breeze Icons REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D12992 To: lshoravi, #vdg, ngraham, #elisa Cc: abetts, paullesur, januz, astippich, mgallien, alex-l, andreask, kde-frameworks-devel, ssteffen, lcmscheid, nhuisman, ursjoss,

D12992: New elisa icon

abetts added a comment. I think we are trying hard to accommodate and the elements are not lending themselves to turn them into an E with some musical tones. I reviewed a few music sheets looking for commonalities. I feel also that the icon is busy, it is trying really hard to tell you that

D12992: New elisa icon

januz added a comment. In D12992#267534 , @lshoravi wrote: > I agree in that a circle doesn't have as much personality as maybe a > casette. I also agree in that the casette felt off when looking at it. > > How would something like an LP

D12992: New elisa icon

mgallien added a subscriber: paullesur. mgallien added a comment. @januz and @astippich I really understand your point of view about the current icon. I share your point of view the need to have an icon easy to differentiate from many other players. For example, I would like Elisa be easy

D12992: New elisa icon

astippich added a comment. In D12992#266673 , @mgallien wrote: > In D12992#266288 , @alex-l wrote: > > > F5863162: image.png > > > > ^ I'm for this one

D12992: New elisa icon

lshoravi added a comment. I agree in that a circle doesn't have as much personality as maybe a casette. I also agree in that the casette felt off when looking at it. How would something like an LP player with the E on top feel? I won't have time until Monday (finals coming up), but my

D12992: New elisa icon

januz added a comment. TBH I like the concept of the cassette icon more than the current implementation of it. What was good about about is that it had //personality//, which is a big deal since usually icons also double as logos. IMO a solid icon should be 1) Memorable and 2) Descriptive.

D12992: New elisa icon

ngraham added a comment. Without meaning to offend whoever made the cassette icon, I think any variant of the one proposed here is hugely better. If I recall, I wasn't overly fond of the cassette icon when it was first proposed and predicted that it would not be popular. Sure enough, that's

D12992: New elisa icon

januz added a comment. In D12992#266673 , @mgallien wrote: > In D12992#266288 , @alex-l wrote: > > > F5863162: image.png > > > > ^ I'm for this one without

D12992: New elisa icon

mgallien added subscribers: astippich, januz. mgallien added a comment. In D12992#266288 , @alex-l wrote: > F5863162: image.png > > ^ I'm for this one without the quaver I also prefer this one

D12992: New elisa icon

ngraham added a subscriber: mgallien. ngraham added a comment. Let's make sure that @mgallien has a say as well. It's for his app, after all! :) REPOSITORY R266 Breeze Icons REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D12992 To: lshoravi, #vdg, ngraham, #elisa Cc: mgallien, alex-l,

D12992: New elisa icon

alex-l added a comment. F5863162: image.png ^ I'm for this one without the quaver F5862923: image.png ^ or this one with white symbol REPOSITORY R266 Breeze Icons REVISION DETAIL

D12992: New elisa icon

lshoravi added a comment. **This** works pretty well, though. F5863172: image.png F5863176: image.png What's the consensus? REPOSITORY R266 Breeze Icons REVISION DETAIL

D12992: New elisa icon

lshoravi added a comment. Last thing I try for tonight. F5863162: image.png White works *fairly* well, but still not all that preferable F5863167: image.png REPOSITORY R266 Breeze Icons REVISION

D12992: New elisa icon

alex-l added a comment. In D12992#266121 , @lshoravi wrote: > Here's a different iteration > > F5862923: image.png > > The e is "supposed" to double as a clef, but it might also be a little noisy

D12992: New elisa icon

lshoravi added a comment. The suggestion above is too noisy. Its useless at low sizes. This is another suggestion, but the drawback was that it has no relation to elisa itself. F5862982: image.png REPOSITORY R266 Breeze Icons REVISION

D12992: New elisa icon

abetts added a subscriber: andreask. REPOSITORY R266 Breeze Icons REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D12992 To: lshoravi, #vdg, ngraham, #elisa Cc: andreask, kde-frameworks-devel, ssteffen, lcmscheid, nhuisman, ursjoss, mykolak, jussiv, michaelh, ognarb, januz, ngraham, bruns,

D12992: New elisa icon

lshoravi added a comment. It's not very 'breezy' though... REPOSITORY R266 Breeze Icons REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D12992 To: lshoravi, #vdg, ngraham, #elisa Cc: kde-frameworks-devel, ssteffen, lcmscheid, nhuisman, ursjoss, mykolak, jussiv, michaelh, ognarb, januz,

D12992: New elisa icon

lshoravi added a comment. Here's a different iteration F5862923: image.png The e is "supposed" to double as a clef, but it might also be a little noisy REPOSITORY R266 Breeze Icons REVISION DETAIL https://phabricator.kde.org/D12992 To:

D12992: New elisa icon

ngraham added a reviewer: Elisa. ngraham added a comment. Very nice in general! I feel like the "e" wrapping around the musical note is a nice concept, but it looks a bit busy to me. In particular, the musical note kinds of blends in and becomes indistinct. And the "e" reminds me of the one

D12992: New elisa icon

lshoravi created this revision. lshoravi added reviewers: VDG, ngraham. lshoravi added a project: Elisa. Restricted Application added a project: Frameworks. Restricted Application added a subscriber: kde-frameworks-devel. lshoravi requested review of this revision. REVISION SUMMARY New elisa