Re: [LEAPSECS] a big week for leaps at SG7 and WP7A

2014-09-30 Thread Stephen Colebourne
That Matsakis document includes reference to the UK public dialogue. I took part in that dialogue at one point as an expert on the topic. The people (regular members of the public, randomly selected) involved were taught what leap seconds were, and given opinions on whether they should stay or go.

Re: [LEAPSECS] a big week for leaps at SG7 and WP7A

2014-09-30 Thread Tony Finch
Stephen Colebourne scolebou...@joda.org wrote: I can safely say from my experience there, that if leap seconds are abolished it will not be with the British peoples approval. I got the impression from the emphasis on non-technical aspects that the consultation was designed to get that answer.

Re: [LEAPSECS] a big week for leaps at SG7 and WP7A

2014-09-30 Thread Stephen Colebourne
On 30 September 2014 11:43, Tony Finch d...@dotat.at wrote: Stephen Colebourne scolebou...@joda.org wrote: I can safely say from my experience there, that if leap seconds are abolished it will not be with the British peoples approval. I got the impression from the emphasis on non-technical

Re: [LEAPSECS] a big week for leaps at SG7 and WP7A

2014-09-30 Thread Michael Spacefalcon
Tony Finch d...@dotat.at wrote: And I seem to remember from reading the materials that they also ignored the cultural damage that was done by the introduction of leap seconds in the first place, breaking a multi-thousand-year tradition of base 60 fractions, making all mechanical clocks

Re: [LEAPSECS] a big week for leaps at SG7 and WP7A

2014-09-30 Thread Kevin Birth
As a social scientist who watched the British process from the outside, I had some concerns about it. In particular, I was bothered by Minister Willets announcing his feelings and THEN hiring the outside consulting group to write a report. Social and cultural dimensions do matter, but if

Re: [LEAPSECS] a big week for leaps at SG7 and WP7A

2014-09-30 Thread Gerard Ashton
Sorry, but I disagree with Tony Finch. The time period from June 30, 2012, 7:59:60 to June 30, 2012, 8:00:00, Eastern Daylight Time, did occur in the United States and any end user requiring such precision was legally obliged to observe it. -Original Message- From: LEAPSECS

Re: [LEAPSECS] a big week for leaps at SG7 and WP7A

2014-09-30 Thread Warner Losh
On Sep 30, 2014, at 8:27 AM, Michael Spacefalcon msoko...@ivan.harhan.org wrote: Tony Finch d...@dotat.at wrote: And I seem to remember from reading the materials that they also ignored the cultural damage that was done by the introduction of leap seconds in the first place, breaking a

[LEAPSECS] Do lawyers care (know) about leap seconds?

2014-09-30 Thread Hal Murray
So you are saying that the UTC standard is so broken that you have to invent your own, which is not standardized by any standards body[*], to get around it? UTC is the required time base for business and has some odd quirks which mean that to comply with it you have to be an expert on the

Re: [LEAPSECS] Do lawyers care (know) about leap seconds?

2014-09-30 Thread Gerard Ashton
I think lots of contracts for the use of computers where time matters, such as online auction sites, contain language that the parties agree to use the time as maintained on a particular computer system, such as the electronic auction site's computers. -Original Message- From: LEAPSECS

Re: [LEAPSECS] Do lawyers care (know) about leap seconds?

2014-09-30 Thread Clive D.W. Feather
Hal Murray said: How many contracts worry about seconds? Ones to deal with electronic trading, domain name registration, and such topics. I think it's common for contracts to start one minute before or after midnight to avoid an English language ambiguity. Things like midnight Monday

Re: [LEAPSECS] Do lawyers care (know) about leap seconds?

2014-09-30 Thread Brooks Harris
Television, cable, and internet advertising. In broadcast (including cable) the contracts are in video frames, in the North America and other NTSC standards countries this is on the order of +- 1/30th second (with some small variance for technical error). Lots and lots of commercials, lots

Re: [LEAPSECS] Do lawyers care (know) about leap seconds?

2014-09-30 Thread Rob Seaman
On Sep 30, 2014, at 3:46 PM, Warner Losh i...@bsdimp.com wrote: But the basic point still remains: If you have to sugar coat the actual standard with a fake standard to paper-over people’s inability to deal with the actual standard, this suggests that you have the wrong actual standard. No,

Re: [LEAPSECS] Do lawyers care (know) about leap seconds?

2014-09-30 Thread Warner Losh
On Sep 30, 2014, at 5:05 PM, Rob Seaman sea...@noao.edu wrote: On Sep 30, 2014, at 3:46 PM, Warner Losh i...@bsdimp.com wrote: But the basic point still remains: If you have to sugar coat the actual standard with a fake standard to paper-over people’s inability to deal with the actual