Re: [OSM-legal-talk] Combining Creative Commons Licensed Data with ODbL and Redistributing

2012-11-28 Thread maning sambale
+1 I'm interested on clarifying this one as well. On Wed, Nov 28, 2012 at 11:02 AM, Kate Chapman k...@maploser.com wrote: Hi All, Currently in Indonesia we are working on a QGIS plugin called InaSAFE. The software allows someone to run an impact analysis of the effect of a certain type of

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] Combining Creative Commons Licensed Data with ODbL and Redistributing

2012-11-28 Thread Richard Fairhurst
Kate Chapman wrote: So is the new dataset a derived database? It seems like it is to me. What should we be licensing this? CC-BY is pretty much compatible with ODbL: CC-BY only requires attribution and ODbL provides that. There may be tiny differences of legalese but nothing substantive. So

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] Combining Creative Commons Licensed Data with ODbL and Redistributing

2012-11-28 Thread Henning Scholland
Am 28.11.2012 04:02, schrieb Kate Chapman: So is the new dataset a derived database? It seems like it is to me. If you combine both datasets to a new one, you've generated a derived database. But this isn't a problem at all, because CC-BY-data can also be licensed under ODbL. Attribution

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] Combining Creative Commons Licensed Data with ODbL and Redistributing

2012-11-28 Thread Rob Myers
On 28/11/12 12:37, Kate Chapman wrote: I don't believe that would apply to a derivative work, I think that just applies to the work itself. I'm interested to hear other interpretations though. It's not particularly coherent given the obvious intent of the licence, but I think the anti-TPM

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] Combining Creative Commons Licensed Data with ODbL and Redistributing

2012-11-28 Thread Shu Higashi
So basically right now the hazard database is licensed CC-BY Maybe different from the intent of the owner of the hazard database, it won't be covered by CC-BY if the hazard database consist only of fact datasets. Though I don't know the exact legal interoperability between ODbL and CC-BY. Shu

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] Combining Creative Commons Licensed Data with ODbL and Redistributing

2012-11-28 Thread Paul Norman
We've been using CC BY licensed data in OSM. The only potential issue is that they be satisfied that the attribution is reasonable to the medium or means You are utilizing. I would consider that a line saying Hazard Data (C) CC BY foo, Map Data (C) ODbL OpenStreetMap contributors with appropriate