Re: [OSM-legal-talk] About CC-4.0 and ODbl

2013-10-05 Thread Tadeusz Knapik
Hello, But doesn't BY-SA claim to cover the database rights? Doesn't that clash with the ODbL? A produced work isn't a database, so BY-SA 4's (proposed) protection of database rights can't be relevant to it, surely. I'm very happy if this is the case. To clarify, as far as I understand

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] About CC-4.0 and ODbl

2013-10-04 Thread Jukka Rahkonen
Rob Myers rob@... writes: On 03/10/13 04:32 AM, Jonathan Harley wrote: On 02/10/13 18:59, Rob Myers wrote: Is it possible to have a BY-SA 4.0 Produced Work? It's possible to give a produced work derived from OSM any license you like (if that's what you mean?) so long as it retains

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] About CC-4.0 and ODbl

2013-10-04 Thread Rob Myers
On 03/10/13 10:06 AM, Jonathan Harley wrote: On 03/10/13 17:21, Rob Myers wrote: On 03/10/13 04:32 AM, Jonathan Harley wrote: On 02/10/13 18:59, Rob Myers wrote: Is it possible to have a BY-SA 4.0 Produced Work? It's possible to give a produced work derived from OSM any license you like (if

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] About CC-4.0 and ODbl

2013-10-03 Thread Jonathan Harley
On 02/10/13 18:59, Rob Myers wrote: On 01/10/13 03:48 AM, Jonathan Harley wrote: On 01/10/13 06:01, Stephan Knauss wrote: On 01.10.2013 06:28, Pekka Sarkola wrote: Questions: Is CC-BY-4.0 compatible with OSM current license (ODbl)? If data is released under CC-BY-4.0: can we import it to OSM?

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] About CC-4.0 and ODbl

2013-10-03 Thread Rob Myers
On 03/10/13 04:32 AM, Jonathan Harley wrote: On 02/10/13 18:59, Rob Myers wrote: Is it possible to have a BY-SA 4.0 Produced Work? It's possible to give a produced work derived from OSM any license you like (if that's what you mean?) so long as it retains OSM's attribution. Including all

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] About CC-4.0 and ODbl

2013-10-02 Thread Rob Myers
On 01/10/13 03:48 AM, Jonathan Harley wrote: On 01/10/13 06:01, Stephan Knauss wrote: On 01.10.2013 06:28, Pekka Sarkola wrote: Questions: Is CC-BY-4.0 compatible with OSM current license (ODbl)? If data is released under CC-BY-4.0: can we import it to OSM? To my understanding not even ODbL

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] About CC-4.0 and ODbl

2013-10-01 Thread Pekka Sarkola
...@stephans-server.de] Lähetetty: 1. lokakuuta 2013 8:01 Vastaanottaja: legal-talk@openstreetmap.org Aihe: Re: [OSM-legal-talk] About CC-4.0 and ODbl On 01.10.2013 06:28, Pekka Sarkola wrote: Questions: Is CC-BY-4.0 compatible with OSM current license (ODbl)? If data is released under CC-BY-4.0: can

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] About CC-4.0 and ODbl

2013-10-01 Thread Jonathan Harley
On 01/10/13 06:01, Stephan Knauss wrote: On 01.10.2013 06:28, Pekka Sarkola wrote: Questions: Is CC-BY-4.0 compatible with OSM current license (ODbl)? If data is released under CC-BY-4.0: can we import it to OSM? To my understanding not even ODbL would be suitable for import into OSM. To be

[OSM-legal-talk] About CC-4.0 and ODbl

2013-09-30 Thread Pekka Sarkola
Dear Friends, Finnish Government is preparing their general open data license. Now there is period of public discussion about new guidelines. You can also participate: http://www.jhs-suositukset.fi/web/guest/news/palautepyynto-avointen-tietoain eistojen-kayttolupa. Yes, It is in Finnish. Maybe

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] About CC-4.0 and ODbl

2013-09-30 Thread Stephan Knauss
On 01.10.2013 06:28, Pekka Sarkola wrote: Questions: Is CC-BY-4.0 compatible with OSM current license (ODbl)? If data is released under CC-BY-4.0: can we import it to OSM? To my understanding not even ODbL would be suitable for import into OSM. To be suitable for OSM it must conform with the