Re: [OSM-legal-talk] Maxspeed tags in Australia

2012-01-06 Thread Nick Hocking
Hendrik wrote There is the possibility to declare a changeset als OK Hi Hendrik, In this case it is essential to actually get rid of the maxspeed tags. The bot used a completly wrong algorithm and the data is dangerously wrong. Just today I drove down a high traffic road where OSM (curtesy of

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] Maxspeed tags in Australia

2012-01-06 Thread Frederik Ramm
Hi, On 01/06/12 11:38, Nick Hocking wrote: In this case it is essential to actually get rid of the maxspeed tags. The bot used a completly wrong algorithm and the data is dangerously wrong. Just today I drove down a high traffic road where OSM (curtesy of the bot) had the wrong max speed).

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] Maxspeed tags in Australia

2012-01-06 Thread Nick Hocking
Frederik wrote Is there a consensus in the Australian communitiy that these tags are worthless and should be removed How many votes do I need :-) The extent of the Australian community is unclear to me due to recent problems. However these edits will have to be removed eventually since both

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] Maxspeed tags in Australia

2012-01-06 Thread Frederik Ramm
Hi, On 01/06/12 12:08, Nick Hocking wrote: Is there a consensus in the Australian communitiy that these tags are worthless and should be removed How many votes do I need :-) Well, nobody shouting stop, stop, these tags are useful to me! would already be a start. I can see only two ways to

Re: [OSM-legal-talk] Maxspeed tags in Australia

2012-01-06 Thread Nick Hocking
Frederik wrote Well, nobody shouting stop, stop, these tags are useful to me! would already be a start. Although the usefullness(or correctness) of these tags is not being discussed in talk-au, there appears to be a concensus (7-0) about removing them now. Tomorrow and Sunday, I'll trawl