Re: [lfs-dev] Version SVN, chapt 5 and 6 adjustments proposal

2018-06-19 Thread Bruce Dubbs
On 06/19/2018 09:30 AM, Xi Ruoyao wrote: On 2018-06-19 09:45 -0400, Jean-Marc Pigeon wrote: A) rename: Libstdc++-8.1.0 -> GCC-8.1.0-pass2 GCC-8.1.0-pass2 -> GCC-8.1.0-pass3 There is no libstdc++ package as such (all other entries use package name), in chapter 6 libstdc++ is generated by a

Re: [lfs-dev] Version SVN, chapt 5 and 6 adjustments proposal

2018-06-19 Thread Jean-Marc Pigeon
Hello, On 06/19/2018 11:27 AM, Bruce Dubbs wrote: [...] Do we really need to tell the user how to do this? It is optional and the user should really have the knowledge now of how to do this. I've never has a student ask how to do it. They do ask the question "Do I need to do this?" but

Re: [lfs-dev] Version SVN, chapt 5 and 6 adjustments proposal

2018-06-19 Thread Alain Toussaint
> Experience: > I removed /tools after "stripping again" > so far so good > But later on I a had a doubt about GCC, so I recompile it and > "make -k check" > and this time, check test was a total mess... You need tcl, expect and dejagnu in the final LFS system (i.e. chapter 6) to solve the

Re: [lfs-dev] Version SVN, chapt 5 and 6 adjustments proposal

2018-06-19 Thread Ken Moffat
On Tue, Jun 19, 2018 at 01:24:36PM -0400, Jean-Marc Pigeon wrote: > > so the question to be asked (no mean intended), > if at the end of chapter-06, it is not yet a Linux, when > in the "Linux from Scratch" process could we declare > "Bingo!, we have a Linux". > When the new system has

Re: [lfs-dev] Version SVN, chapt 5 and 6 adjustments proposal

2018-06-19 Thread Bruce Dubbs
On 06/19/2018 12:24 PM, Jean-Marc Pigeon wrote: Hello, On 06/19/2018 11:27 AM, Bruce Dubbs wrote: [...] Do we really need to tell the user how to do this?  It is optional and the user should really have the knowledge now of how to do this.  I've never has a student ask how to do it.  They

Re: [lfs-dev] Version SVN, chapt 5 and 6 adjustments proposal

2018-06-19 Thread Jean-Marc Pigeon
Bonjour Alain, On 06/19/2018 01:30 PM, Alain Toussaint wrote: Experience: I removed /tools after "stripping again" so far so good But later on I a had a doubt about GCC, so I recompile it and "make -k check" and this time, check test was a total mess... You need tcl, expect and dejagnu in

Re: [lfs-dev] Version SVN, chapt 5 and 6 adjustments proposal

2018-06-19 Thread Jean-Marc Pigeon
On 06/19/2018 01:35 PM, Ken Moffat wrote: On Tue, Jun 19, 2018 at 01:24:36PM -0400, Jean-Marc Pigeon wrote: so the question to be asked (no mean intended), if at the end of chapter-06, it is not yet a Linux, when in the "Linux from Scratch" process could we declare "Bingo!, we have a Linux".

[lfs-dev] Version SVN, chapt 5 and 6 adjustments proposal

2018-06-19 Thread Jean-Marc Pigeon
Hello, 3 adjustments proposal. 5. Constructing a Temporary System A) rename: Libstdc++-8.1.0 -> GCC-8.1.0-pass2 GCC-8.1.0-pass2 -> GCC-8.1.0-pass3 There is no libstdc++ package as such (all other entries use package name), in chapter 6 libstdc++ is generated by a standard GCC build. I think

Re: [lfs-dev] Version SVN, chapt 5 and 6 adjustments proposal

2018-06-19 Thread Jean-Marc Pigeon
Hello, On 06/19/2018 10:30 AM, Xi Ruoyao wrote: On 2018-06-19 09:45 -0400, Jean-Marc Pigeon wrote: A) rename: Libstdc++-8.1.0 -> GCC-8.1.0-pass2 GCC-8.1.0-pass2 -> GCC-8.1.0-pass3 There is no libstdc++ package as such (all other entries use package name), in chapter 6 libstdc++ is generated

Re: [lfs-dev] Version SVN, chapt 5 and 6 adjustments proposal

2018-06-19 Thread Xi Ruoyao
On 2018-06-19 09:45 -0400, Jean-Marc Pigeon wrote: > A) > rename: > Libstdc++-8.1.0 -> GCC-8.1.0-pass2 > GCC-8.1.0-pass2 -> GCC-8.1.0-pass3 > > There is no libstdc++ package as such (all > other entries use package name), in chapter 6 > libstdc++ is generated by a standard GCC build. > I think