Re: [lfs-support] [blfs-support] GRUB (x-post)

2014-01-29 Thread Bruce Dubbs
Merell L. Matlock, Jr. wrote:
> On 01/28/14 12:13, Bruce Dubbs wrote:
>> Merell L. Matlock, Jr. wrote:
>>> Hopefully, I'm posting to the right list...my Duck-Duck-Go/Google-fu has
>>> finally abandoned me.
>>>
>>> My (B)LFS system is complete and screaming right along, except for one
>>> little issue...GRUB.
>>>
>>> I had originally installed Mint 15 to be my host for LFS build. Mint's
>>> grub properly detected the Win 7 partition, and when I was finished with
>>> LFS, detected that as well.
>>>
>>> I haven't been back to either Mint or Win 7 since my original LFS boot,
>>> and I would really like to have all the GRUB info/configs on my BLFS
>>> system, but really have no idea (and can't seem to locate any hints) to
>>> accomplish this.
>>>
>>> Ideas or pointers would be deeply appreciated.
>>
>> GRUB was built in LFS Chapter 6 and the configuration covered in LFS
>> Chapter 8.  If you already installed GRUB, I hope you made a copy of
>> grub.cfg.  You can try to run grub-mkconfig to see if it finds mint
>> and W7.  Make a backup of a working grub.cfg first.
>>
>>-- Bruce
>>
>>
> 
>
> I heeded the very *first* warning in Chap 8.4.  All of the grub
> configuration/information is in the /boot directory in the mint
> partition.  I didn't install grub on LFS.

That's fine, but the LFS kernel needs to be in mint's /boot.  That type 
of problem is one reason why I always recommend a separate /boot 
partition.  That way all distros use the same one.

> Then there is this, from grub info:
>
> * At least on BIOS systems, if you tell `grub-install' to install grub
> to a partition but grub has already been installed in the master boot
> record, then the grub installation in the partition will be ignored.

I don't know how GRUB would install itself to a partition.  I don't know 
where there is space.


> Anyway, I went ahead and installed grub and overwrote the MBR. Booted
> fine, but mkconfig did not find the mint or win7 partitions.

That's because it only looked in the LFS /boot directory.

> I copied
> over the menu entries from the mint partition and all is ok.

I would expect that.

   -- Bruce
-- 
http://linuxfromscratch.org/mailman/listinfo/lfs-support
FAQ: http://www.linuxfromscratch.org/lfs/faq.html
Unsubscribe: See the above information page


Re: [lfs-support] [blfs-support] GRUB (x-post)

2014-01-29 Thread Merell L. Matlock, Jr.
On 01/28/14 12:13, Bruce Dubbs wrote:
> Merell L. Matlock, Jr. wrote:
>> Hopefully, I'm posting to the right list...my Duck-Duck-Go/Google-fu has
>> finally abandoned me.
>>
>> My (B)LFS system is complete and screaming right along, except for one
>> little issue...GRUB.
>>
>> I had originally installed Mint 15 to be my host for LFS build. Mint's
>> grub properly detected the Win 7 partition, and when I was finished with
>> LFS, detected that as well.
>>
>> I haven't been back to either Mint or Win 7 since my original LFS boot,
>> and I would really like to have all the GRUB info/configs on my BLFS
>> system, but really have no idea (and can't seem to locate any hints) to
>> accomplish this.
>>
>> Ideas or pointers would be deeply appreciated.
>
> GRUB was built in LFS Chapter 6 and the configuration covered in LFS 
> Chapter 8.  If you already installed GRUB, I hope you made a copy of 
> grub.cfg.  You can try to run grub-mkconfig to see if it finds mint 
> and W7.  Make a backup of a working grub.cfg first.
>
>   -- Bruce
>
>


I heeded the very *first* warning in Chap 8.4.  All of the grub 
configuration/information is in the /boot directory in the mint 
partition.  I didn't install grub on LFS.

Then there is this, from grub info:

* At least on BIOS systems, if you tell `grub-install' to install grub 
to a partition but grub has already been installed in the master boot 
record, then the grub installation in the partition will be ignored.

Anyway, I went ahead and installed grub and overwrote the MBR. Booted 
fine, but mkconfig did not find the mint or win7 partitions.  I copied 
over the menu entries from the mint partition and all is ok.

Thanks,

Merell Matlock



-- 
http://linuxfromscratch.org/mailman/listinfo/lfs-support
FAQ: http://www.linuxfromscratch.org/lfs/faq.html
Unsubscribe: See the above information page