Re: Eiffel Forum License

2000-04-30 Thread Roger Browne
"Rod Dixon, J.D., LL.M." wrote: The Eiffel "license" ... ... may be too "permissive" to constitute an enforceable agreement...in that it appears to lack consideration. I am aware that in some countries, a consideration is required to make a contract enforceable. But does that also apply to

RE: Eiffel Forum License

2000-04-30 Thread Rod Dixon, J.D., LL.M.
I have not read the BSD licenses in a while, but I know that the FSF/Richard Stallman argues that they have no copyleft provision. Again, the absence of a copyleft provision in a public license is not a critical failure to maintaining an open source/free software project, but the absence of

RE: Eiffel Forum License

2000-04-30 Thread Patrick Doyle
On Sun, 30 Apr 2000, Rod Dixon, J.D., LL.M. wrote: Someone, I have forgotten who, sorry, made an interesting comment about the enforceability of GPLs, generally. I agree that it is an open question whether a court would enforce some public licenses. If a license lacks consideration, it's

Re: Eiffel Forum License

2000-04-30 Thread Rick Moen
Quoting Rod Dixon, J.D., LL.M. ([EMAIL PROTECTED]): Someone, I have forgotten who, sorry, made an interesting comment about the enforceability of GPLs, generally. I agree that it is an open question whether a court would enforce some public licenses. If a license lacks consideration, it's

RE: Eiffel Forum License

2000-04-30 Thread David Johnson
On Sun, 30 Apr 2000, Patrick Doyle wrote: Legally, you can do two things: 1. Adhere to the terms of the license. 2. Don't make copies of the software. Is it not that simple? (Please excuse my ignorance. :-) That's the way I have always viewed licenses. You have a limited set of rights

RE: Eiffel Forum License

2000-04-30 Thread Patrick Doyle
On Sun, 30 Apr 2000, David Johnson wrote: On Sun, 30 Apr 2000, Patrick Doyle wrote: Legally, you can do two things: 1. Adhere to the terms of the license. 2. Don't make copies of the software. Is it not that simple? (Please excuse my ignorance. :-) [...] I have a big

RE: Eiffel Forum License

2000-04-30 Thread David Johnson
On Sun, 30 Apr 2000, Rod Dixon, J.D., LL.M. wrote: I have not read the BSD licenses in a while, but I know that the FSF/Richard Stallman argues that they have no copyleft provision. ... Consequently, I think this is a rather appropriate time to discuss the BSD and other public licenses. I