Should governmnet software be Open Source?

2000-03-08 Thread Brice, Richard
Here is a question I'd like to get some thoughts on... Should software written by our government be Open Source? After all, we pay for it. I think we be given the opportunity to find new and creative uses for it. I think open sourcing this software could also serve to make government more

Re: Should governmnet software be Open Source?

2000-03-08 Thread Derek J. Balling
Government-written and government-contracted software is NOT Open Source, but it IS Public Domain. Knowing the differences is left as an exercise for the reader, but if you want the source code, a FOIA request would probably turn it up for you in short order. D At 10:17 AM 3/8/00 -0800,

RE: Should governmnet software be Open Source?

2000-03-08 Thread Brice, Richard
e denied the maximum benefit of their investment. -Original Message- From: Derek J. Balling [SMTP:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] Sent: Wednesday, March 08, 2000 10:26 AM To: Brice, Richard; '[EMAIL PROTECTED]' Subject:Re: Should governmnet sof

RE: Should governmnet software be Open Source?

2000-03-08 Thread Derek J. Balling
At 10:52 AM 3/8/00 -0800, Brice, Richard wrote: Public domain and Open Source are not the same thing... No problem with that. However, I've seen government agencies exercise their right to copyright material (at least I assume it is their right because it is done frequently). It would be

RE: Should governmnet software be Open Source?

2000-03-08 Thread Brice, Richard
Cc: '[EMAIL PROTECTED]' Subject:RE: Should governmnet software be Open Source? At 10:52 AM 3/8/00 -0800, Brice, Richard wrote: Public domain and Open Source are not the same thing... No problem with that. However, I've seen government agencies

Re: Should governmnet software be Open Source?

2000-03-08 Thread Seth David Schoen
Derek J. Balling writes: At 10:52 AM 3/8/00 -0800, Brice, Richard wrote: Public domain and Open Source are not the same thing... No problem with that. But public domain is one form of Open Source; see below. As a specific example, the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation has written

Re: Should governmnet software be Open Source?

2000-03-08 Thread Rick B. Dietz
Is anyone familiar with the IRS's effort to create free (as in beer) tax software? As I recall, Congress shut this project down at the behest of Intuit, et al. The argument was the same as that often made against the USPS, government intrusion in the market space of what would otherwise be a

Re: Should governmnet software be Open Source?

2000-03-08 Thread Derek J. Balling
At 04:13 PM 3/8/00 -0500, Rick B. Dietz wrote: The issue to the IRS was not that it was competing with commercial services, rather it was making interaction with an existing government beaurocracy easier for citizens for nothing over the internet. Intuit was saying, wait a second, we like this

Re: Should governmnet software be Open Source?

2000-03-08 Thread Seth David Schoen
Derek J. Balling writes: At 11:37 AM 3/8/00 -0800, Seth David Schoen wrote: At 10:52 AM 3/8/00 -0800, Brice, Richard wrote: Public domain and Open Source are not the same thing... No problem with that. But public domain is one form of Open Source; see below. Fair enough, BUT, I

Re: Should governmnet software be Open Source?

2000-03-08 Thread Mark Wells
On Wed, 8 Mar 2000, Seth David Schoen wrote: This is a difficult argument; after all, paying taxes does not allow you to attend a public university without being admitted, nor to enter government buildings and offices or military bases. I think the difference here is precisely that

Re: Should governmnet software be Open Source?

2000-03-08 Thread David Johnson
On Wed, 08 Mar 2000, Brice, Richard wrote: Here is a question I'd like to get some thoughts on... Should software written by our government be Open Source? After all, we pay for it. I think we be given the opportunity to find new and creative uses for it. Of course! And more than that, it