RE: Do programs compiled with a GNU compiler have to be open source?

2000-10-30 Thread Dave J Woolley
From: Andrew J Bromage [SMTP:[EMAIL PROTECTED]] I would think that it would be exceedingly hard to argue that the output of a compiler is a derivative work of (or "work based on") the compiler or any standard libraries that must be provided as part of a conforming [DJW:] The FSF

Re: Nupedia Open Content License

2000-10-30 Thread Rod Dixon, J.D., LL.M.
A point of clarification on fair use. "Fair use" is based on copyright. Hence, the license may control uses that would otherwise be deemed fair uses under the default rules of copyright. In this respect, it is not consistent with open source philosophy to specify what uses the licensor considers

Re: Nupedia Open Content License

2000-10-30 Thread John Cowan
"Rod Dixon, J.D., LL.M." wrote: A point of clarification on fair use. "Fair use" is based on copyright. Quite so. As you know (or should have known :-) ), I hold that an open-source license can only grant away the rights that the copyright owner gets from the applicable copyright law,

Re: Nupedia Open Content License

2000-10-30 Thread Rod Dixon, J.D., LL.M.
John, We are in agreement. My point was simple - - although my explanation was too laconic, sorry about that - - you are far better of by keeping fair use issues out of the license. Rod - Original Message - From: "John Cowan" [EMAIL PROTECTED] To: "Rod Dixon, J.D., LL.M." [EMAIL