Is inherited class a derivative work?

2001-10-13 Thread Michael Beck
We have a discussion going on internally about inheritance. Some people believe that when you subclass/inherit/derive a new class, you are creating a derivative work in the copyright sense, especially when you override existing methods. Others believe that inheritance is delegation of

Re: Is inherited class a derivative work?

2001-10-13 Thread Greg London
Michael Beck wrote: Some people believe that when you subclass a new class, you are creating a derivative work in the copyright sense, especially when you override existing methods. The scary scenario is that somebody will inherit a class, make some modifications to it, and then claim

Re: Approval request, DSPL v1.1

2001-10-13 Thread John Cowan
Julian Hall scripsit: Having quickly scanned the archives of the license discussion mailing list I can't find much reference from when I submitted version 1.0, but I did note that there was some concern about the license requiring the committee to be an incorporated body. IANAL TINLA YADA

Re: Approval request, DSPL v1.1

2001-10-13 Thread Matthew C. Weigel
On Sat, 13 Oct 2001, Julian Hall wrote: Following comments I received on version 1.0 of the DSPL, I have prepared a revision for submission for approval. Here are my comments: Section 3, use of the software, seems to be fairly irrelevant. Surely simply saying use of the software is not

Re: Is inherited class a derivative work?

2001-10-13 Thread David Johnson
On Saturday 13 October 2001 03:54 am, Michael Beck wrote: We have a discussion going on internally about inheritance. Some people believe that when you subclass/inherit/derive a new class, you are creating a derivative work in the copyright sense, especially when you override existing

Re: Is inherited class a derivative work?

2001-10-13 Thread John Cowan
David Johnson scripsit: A derivative work must contain at least portions of the original work. I know what you mean, but that's poorly worded. Translations, for example, don't contain any literal portion of the original, but are paradigm cases of derivative works. Dependency alone does not