Re: Can anyone say his or her software is open source?

2001-11-01 Thread Tina Gasperson
Thanks to everyone for the input on my question regarding ACARA, NASA, and Open Channel Software. I spoke to John Kennedy, the president (of OCS :)) and as a result of our conversation he decided to remove the phrase Open Source from the motto that displays on the top of each page at their sit

RE: Can anyone say his or her software is open source?

2001-10-31 Thread Lawrence E. Rosen
> From: Matthew C. Weigel > The Open Source Initiative owns the servicemark "OSI Approved Open > Source Software," and that is all. Not quite! The certification mark is "OSI Certified" and the goods are "open source software." Thus the usage is: OSI Certified Open Source Software /Larry R

Re: Can anyone say his or her software is open source?

2001-10-31 Thread Tina Gasperson
Chris Gray wrote: >>You'll also see that Going To The Media (tm) was proposed and rejected as a first approach: softly softly did it. I'll give them a call this morning, cordially mention some of the points made, and see what the reaction is. -t -- license-discuss archive is at http://crynwr.

Re: Can anyone say his or her software is open source?

2001-10-30 Thread Martin Konold
On Tue, 30 Oct 2001, David Johnson wrote: > On Friday 30 November 2001 03:31 pm, Tina Gasperson wrote: > > ACARA (http://www.openchannelsoftware.com/projects/ACARA) is a program > > originally developed by NASA. ACARA is now being handled by the Open > > Channel Foundation (http://www.openchannel

Re: Can anyone say his or her software is open source?

2001-10-30 Thread David Johnson
On Tuesday 30 October 2001 08:52 pm, Rod Dixon, J.D., LL.M. wrote: > the term or phrase "open source" is generic, and often used as > a marketing phrase in much the same manner as "diet soda" is used. I > cannot imagine what the legal basis would be to bring a fraud claim on > the use the term "o

RE: Can anyone say his or her software is open source?

2001-10-30 Thread Rod Dixon, J.D., LL.M.
The question presented is actually a very good one in my opinion because it calls out a subtle complexity with discussing open source and understanding what is really meant by the various uses (and, possibly, misuses) of the term. I think a programmer may freely identify their software as "closed

Re: Can anyone say his or her software is open source?

2001-10-30 Thread Matthew C. Weigel
On Fri, 30 Nov 2001, Tina Gasperson wrote: > Does a license have to comply with the published requirements > (http://www.opensource.org/docs/definition.html) in order for the distributor > or creator of the software to call it open source? No. It is encouraged socially to 'help the end user' by

Re: Can anyone say his or her software is open source?

2001-10-30 Thread David Johnson
On Friday 30 November 2001 03:31 pm, Tina Gasperson wrote: > ACARA (http://www.openchannelsoftware.com/projects/ACARA) is a program > originally developed by NASA. ACARA is now being handled by the Open > Channel Foundation (http://www.openchannelsoftware.com). ACARA's license > terms > (http://ww