Re: [Lightning-dev] BOLTs and meaning of "MUST" in potentially adversarial contexts

2018-01-15 Thread Rusty Russell
Benjamin Mord writes: > One thing I find useful in RFCs is a brief discussion about the meaning of > terms like MUST, SHOULD, MAY, etc.. as used in the subsequent protocol > definition. Hi Benjamin! Weird, I always find them kinda useless. RFC2119 pretty much covers it. > When a BOLT s

[Lightning-dev] Fee disentanglement for 1.1 spec?

2018-01-15 Thread Rusty Russell
Hi all, Wanted to post some thinking on this for everyone to mull over, though I know we're all busy. Your consideration and feedback gratefully accepted! Problem #1 == For simplicity, one side (funder) sets fees, but other side needs to check they're sufficient, and not insanely

Re: [Lightning-dev] [1.1] Proposed `funding_cancelled` message

2018-01-15 Thread Matt Corallo
Ok, so limit things to 100 channels... Still don't see why the constants get into unreasonable load here... On January 15, 2018 2:53:07 AM UTC, ZmnSCPxj wrote: >Good morning Matt, > >> I can't imagine the constants add up that fast... Allow 25 channels >per peer and limit your peers reasonably a