Re: MIDI title?

2021-11-19 Thread David Kastrup
David Kastrup writes: > I have no idea what my arrangers would display then (maybe they even are > smart enough to fall back to the filename on their own) Turns out they are. Problem is how to convey to Performance::output the difference between "" and no name at all. It is actually

Re: MIDI title?

2021-11-19 Thread David Kastrup
James writes: > Hello > > On 19/11/2021 21:14, Carl Sorensen wrote: >> I think it's reasonable to use the filename, and if the title in the >> MIDI needs to be empty, the user can set it so. >> >> Carl >> > > I agree with Carl - for what my opinion is worth. > > That seems to me to be the

Re: MIDI title?

2021-11-19 Thread James
Hello On 19/11/2021 21:14, Carl Sorensen wrote: I think it's reasonable to use the filename, and if the title in the MIDI needs to be empty, the user can set it so. Carl I agree with Carl - for what my opinion is worth. That seems to me to be the most 'obvious' solution to someone who

Re: MIDI title?

2021-11-19 Thread Carl Sorensen
On 11/19/21, 1:31 PM, "lilypond-devel on behalf of David Kastrup" wrote: Aaron Hill writes: > On 2021-11-19 11:28 am, David Kastrup wrote: >> What are other people's feelings here? Should we allow an explicit >> specification of the title as "" to override such a

Re: MIDI title?

2021-11-19 Thread David Kastrup
Aaron Hill writes: > On 2021-11-19 11:28 am, David Kastrup wrote: >> What are other people's feelings here? Should we allow an explicit >> specification of the title as "" to override such a fallback? > > Could it work to add a midiTitle property/field to allow users more > control? Already

Re: MIDI title?

2021-11-19 Thread Aaron Hill
On 2021-11-19 11:28 am, David Kastrup wrote: What are other people's feelings here? Should we allow an explicit specification of the title as "" to override such a fallback? Could it work to add a midiTitle property/field to allow users more control? The default behavior when midiTitle is