Re: status of spanner IDs across voices?

Hi, The goal was to allow all (or at least many) spanners to be able to cross voices, but I started with dynamics since the engraver seemed relatively simple. I also looked at slurs because of its existing support for simultaneous slurs (in one voice). After experimenting with these with some

Re: cross-voice spanners

Hi Francisco, David Kastrup gave me some feedback on the code I wrote for the project, which needs to be revised/better documented. I haven't had much time to do that, although I am hoping to start the revision after I finish my final examinations. At the moment, I can't give any ETA, but I

Re: [GSoC] Implement cross-voice dynamic spanners (issue 304160043 by starry...@gmail.com)

Hi, I am almost done moving multiple/cross-voice spanner code out of specific engravers into the Spanner_engraver class. I just want to make sure this approach is on the right track before finishing up and submitting the patch: New instances of the engraver are created to handle

Re: GSoC spanners review/update

> \new Staff { << { g\=Staff.1( a b } >> << { c,\newCommand d e\=Staff.1) } >> } > Without the command indicating the slur's change in voice, the d and e > would not be acknowledged by the slur, since it would still belong to > the voice it started in. Correction: the c and d would not be

Re: GSoC spanners review/update

Hello, On Tue, Jul 19, 2016 at 3:20 PM, Trevor Daniels wrote: > You're now a developer AFA SourceForge is concerned, which means you can add > Issues. There are a few more hoops to jump through before you can submit > patches. I have uploaded the patch, thanks.

Re: GSoC spanners review/update

Thank you Simon, Phil, Trevor for the advice On Tue, Jul 19, 2016 at 3:20 AM, Phil Holmes wrote: > AFAICS you don't have permission yet to create issues on Allura. If you > create a SourceForge account and request permission for that account on this > mailing list, Trevor

GSoC spanners review/update

Hello, I have (except for one question below) finished adapting Dynamic_engraver and Dynamic_align_engraver to work cross-voice. I plan to continue with other spanners (perhaps slurs next), but I want to make sure I am on the right track. I organized my current progress in the gsoc-2016-spanners

Re: [GSoC] spanners project update

Hello, A quick question regarding the key-list argument to \= : if the list only has one key, it is assumed to be the id, as the share context is optional. When both the context and id are given, however, should the order of the keys be (context id) or (id context)? I initially implemented the

Re: [GSoC] spanners project update

Hello, (@David: I did not know about that function, thanks) I'm wondering how Dynamic_align_engraver should deal with cross-voice dynamic spanners. I don't have any good ideas at the moment (the best possibility I thought of is to have a DynamicLineSpanner follow a cross-voice dynamic to the

Re: [GSoC] spanners project update

On Tue, Jul 5, 2016 at 1:54 AM, David Kastrup <d...@gnu.org> wrote: > Nathan Chou <starry...@gmail.com> writes: >> That is a good point; I might agree with spanner id's not being shared >> across voices if nothing has been indicated. To make this less >> tedious,

Re: [GSoC] spanners project update

On Fri, Jul 1, 2016 at 12:48 AM, David Kastrup wrote: > But that means that you can no longer let people write individual parts > with several spanner ids independently even when there never is even > going to be any cross-Voice spanner. Spanner-ids like \=1 \=2 are not > likely to

Re: [GSoC] spanners project update

Thanks David and Urs for replying. >> There is a detail I would like to clarify. David suggested allowing \= >> to optionally specify the parent context in which a cross-voice >> spanner's information is shared (although I am not sure how that would >> be done with a key-list, since I think the

Re: [GSoC] spanners project update

Hello, I have tried the same idea with context properties, and it seems to work just as well as my previous approach with a static member. (To summarize: cross voice spanners and the voice they currently belong to are stored in a property of some context containing both voices, like Score. Each

Re: [GSoC] spanners project update

Thank you Dan, David, Jan-Peter; I will try the suggestions out. Nathan On Sun, Jun 26, 2016 at 8:43 AM, Jan-Peter Voigt wrote: > > > Am 26. Juni 2016 17:06:51 MESZ, schrieb David Kastrup : >>Jan-Peter Voigt writes: >> ... >>> Whenever you are up

[GSoC] spanners project update

Hello, Just wanted to update on my progress for the GSoC cross-voice spanners project. The approach I am currently trying uses the existing spanner-id property (which can be set like { c\=hello\< d\=hello\! }); spanners with an id are handled as potentially being cross-voice. Each engraver

Re: GSoC spanners project

it basically does the same thing as the hidden voice workaround? Thanks again! Nathan On Mon, May 16, 2016 at 12:50 AM, David Kastrup <d...@gnu.org> wrote: > Nathan Chou <starry...@gmail.com> writes: > >> Hello, >> >> I have somewhat looked at the code and

Re: GSoC spanners project

Hello, I have somewhat looked at the code and want to confirm my understanding of the current behavior: * While the file is parsed in Scheme, spanners cause a START and STOP event with an appropriate type to be created in the context they belong to * After creation of the Music objects, where

GSoC spanners project

Hello all, I am a second-year student studying computer science at UCLA, and I will be working on the cross-voice spanners project this summer as part of the Google Summer of Code program. I'm glad to have this opportunity to contribute to Lilypond---I've written music with Lilypond before and

Re: starting to contribute (GSoC)

Thank you for your suggestions! I started looking at issue 3947. I found that adjusting baseline-skip can be added to commands like \small in define-markup-commands.scm. But I'm not sure where to look to adjust baseline-skip whenever font-size is overridden not via one of those commands. Also

starting to contribute (GSoC)

Hello, I am a second-year student looking to contribute for Google Summer of Code (and perhaps afterward). I've used Lilypond to make some relatively simple scores before, and have some experience in C/C++ (not yet familiar with Scheme, but learning). I've downloaded LilyDev and successfully