Re: Extract notes from chords, with silence when there are none

2015-09-17 Thread Gilles THIBAULT
> Wrap the whole expression in event-chord-wrap! before handling it. The > LSR issue is probably from before issue 2240 changed the representation > of single notes. > No, it is because "chord.ly" deals only with chords and keeps notes unchanged. But yes, event-chord-wrap! is a quick way here

Re: Extract notes from chords, with silence when there are none

2015-09-17 Thread mskala
On Thu, 17 Sep 2015, Gilles THIBAULT wrote: > So Chris, the last change you have to make in the code is to change > > line 73 (in \extractNote definition) > (extract-note music n)) > > by > > (extract-note (event-chord-wrap! music) n)) Assuming you mean me... I just found a message I thought I'd

Extract notes from chords, with silence when there are none

2015-09-16 Thread mskala
I'd like to take a passage of music that contains chords with differing numbers of notes, and some single notes, and extract it into separate monophonic streams such that their union is the original passage. The application is to generate microtonal MIDI using pitch bend, which can only

Re: Extract notes from chords, with silence when there are none

2015-09-16 Thread Chris Yate
Just to clarify, in the case of 3-voice music, how would you expect it to deal with a 2 note chord? One note to Treble, one to Bass, or one in Treble, one in Alto, or... what? Chris On 16 September 2015 at 13:07, wrote: > I'd like to take a passage of music that

Re: Extract notes from chords, with silence when there are none

2015-09-16 Thread David Kastrup
Chris Yate writes: > Just to clarify, in the case of 3-voice music, how would you expect it to > deal with a 2 note chord? > > One note to Treble, one to Bass, or one in Treble, one in Alto, or... what? As I read him, he does not care. First note anywhere, second note

Re: Extract notes from chords, with silence when there are none

2015-09-16 Thread mskala
On Wed, 16 Sep 2015, David Kastrup wrote: > > Just to clarify, in the case of 3-voice music, how would you expect it to > > deal with a 2 note chord? > > > > One note to Treble, one to Bass, or one in Treble, one in Alto, or... what? > > As I read him, he does not care. First note anywhere,

Re: Extract notes from chords, with silence when there are none

2015-09-16 Thread Thomas Morley
2015-09-16 17:20 GMT+02:00 : > On Wed, 16 Sep 2015, David Kastrup wrote: >> > Just to clarify, in the case of 3-voice music, how would you expect it to >> > deal with a 2 note chord? >> > >> > One note to Treble, one to Bass, or one in Treble, one in Alto, or... what? >>

REĀ : Extract notes from chords, with silence when there are none

2015-09-16 Thread Gilles Thibault
ProvenanceĀ : Courrier pour Windows 10 > That's right. I just want any two notes that play simultaneously to be > returned by separate index values into the extraction function, and any > other index values to return something that will be silent (either a skip > or a rest). I don't want

Re: Extract notes from chords, with silence when there are none

2015-09-16 Thread mskala
On Thu, 17 Sep 2015, msk...@ansuz.sooke.bc.ca wrote: > On my first few attempt to load this page the server didn't respond, but > it seems to work now, and yes, that looks like it does what I want. I spoke too soon: the code doesn't handle single notes (non-chords), so it's not a complete

Re: Extract notes from chords, with silence when there are none

2015-09-16 Thread mskala
On Wed, 16 Sep 2015, Thomas Morley wrote: > Is my recent coding here: > http://www.lilypondforum.de/index.php?topic=2080.msg11479#msg11479 > of any help? On my first few attempt to load this page the server didn't respond, but it seems to work now, and yes, that looks like it does what I want.

Re: Extract notes from chords, with silence when there are none

2015-09-16 Thread David Kastrup
msk...@ansuz.sooke.bc.ca writes: > On Thu, 17 Sep 2015, msk...@ansuz.sooke.bc.ca wrote: >> On my first few attempt to load this page the server didn't respond, but >> it seems to work now, and yes, that looks like it does what I want. > > I spoke too soon: the code doesn't handle single notes