Re: adjusting vertical positions of start and end of tie

2020-08-07 Thread Martín Rincón Botero
Hey Werner, I would try to avoid changing the clef in the middle of a tied note in the first place. I can't imagine any scenario where that's necessary, desired or correct. Best regards, Martín. El El vie, 7 ago 2020 a las 7:41, Werner LEMBERG escribió: > > > you could translate the

Re: adjusting vertical positions of start and end of tie

2020-08-06 Thread Werner LEMBERG
> you could translate the control-points _iff_ left/right-bound's > staff-positions are not equal. Thanks a lot for the code! It's something to have in mind if it becomes *really* necessary. Werner

Re: adjusting vertical positions of start and end of tie

2020-08-06 Thread Werner LEMBERG
> I don't find that Tie supports 'positions. Strange. Seeing Gould's advice it's not so surprising. On the other hand, I'm actually in favor of adding it, for very special situations. > You could do this with \shape used as a tweak. Roughly: > > \relative c' { > \clef "alto" d'2 \shape

Re: adjusting vertical positions of start and end of tie

2020-08-06 Thread Werner LEMBERG
> o "incorrect" has a tie winding its way from one vertical position > to another, in the process wrapping around the new clef sign. Thanks for the info! I just want to mention that in complex piano music even the 'incorrect' solution has to be used from time to time. Note that the problem to

Re: adjusting vertical positions of start and end of tie

2020-08-06 Thread Werner LEMBERG
> I see at least three options: > > - The tie should be sloped like a slur. If you really have to do that (for whatever reason), this is the solution to go IMHO. > - The tie should be split into a two halves (possibly > dotted/dashed), each half attached to the terminal notes but >

Re: adjusting vertical positions of start and end of tie

2020-08-06 Thread Aaron Hill
On 2020-08-06 6:54 pm, Brian Barker wrote: At 15:59 06/08/2020 -0700, Aaron Hill wrote: On 2020-08-06 3:34 pm, Werner LEMBERG wrote: Look at this example \relative c' { \clef "alto" d'2 \tweak positions #'(8 . 4) ~ \clef "treble" d2 } The `\tweak positions` doesn't work ­ which

Re: adjusting vertical positions of start and end of tie

2020-08-06 Thread Brian Barker
At 15:59 06/08/2020 -0700, Aaron Hill wrote: On 2020-08-06 3:34 pm, Werner LEMBERG wrote: Look at this example \relative c' { \clef "alto" d'2 \tweak positions #'(8 . 4) ~ \clef "treble" d2 } The `\tweak positions` doesn't work ­ which is kind-of expected. However, for this very

Re: adjusting vertical positions of start and end of tie

2020-08-06 Thread Thomas Morley
Am Fr., 7. Aug. 2020 um 00:34 Uhr schrieb Werner LEMBERG : > > > > Look at this example > > > > > > \relative c' { > > \clef "alto" d'2 \tweak positions #'(8 . 4) ~ > > \clef "treble" d2 > > } > > > > The `\tweak positions` doesn't work – which is kind-of expected. > > However, for

Re: adjusting vertical positions of start and end of tie

2020-08-06 Thread David Nalesnik
Hi Werner, On Thu, Aug 6, 2020 at 5:33 PM Werner LEMBERG wrote: > > > Look at this example > > > \relative c' { > \clef "alto" d'2 \tweak positions #'(8 . 4) ~ > \clef "treble" d2 > } > > The `\tweak positions` doesn't work – which is kind-of expected. > However, for this very

Re: adjusting vertical positions of start and end of tie

2020-08-06 Thread Aaron Hill
On 2020-08-06 3:34 pm, Werner LEMBERG wrote: Look at this example \relative c' { \clef "alto" d'2 \tweak positions #'(8 . 4) ~ \clef "treble" d2 } The `\tweak positions` doesn't work – which is kind-of expected. However, for this very situation it would be nice if I could change

Re: adjusting vertical positions of start and end of tie

2020-08-06 Thread Werner LEMBERG
> Look at this example > > > \relative c' { > \clef "alto" d'2 \tweak positions #'(8 . 4) ~ > \clef "treble" d2 > } > > The `\tweak positions` doesn't work – which is kind-of expected. > However, for this very situation it would be nice if I could change > the start and end

adjusting vertical positions of start and end of tie

2020-08-06 Thread Werner LEMBERG
Look at this example \relative c' { \clef "alto" d'2 \tweak positions #'(8 . 4) ~ \clef "treble" d2 } The `\tweak positions` doesn't work – which is kind-of expected. However, for this very situation it would be nice if I could change the start and end position of the slur